I am too busy working and
playing hard here in Japan to fully participate in this excellent thread, so I will stick to just a couple of the subtopics, first that of the relative risks of being a victim of violence in the US vs abroad:
WTF, I think that we have read Amanda differently. She said
As a single female traveling alone in an underground industry, I can assure everyone I felt safer in every country I visited (with one exception) than I do walking the streets in American buying groceries. America has many great things about it and many freedoms, it is also incredibly dangerous for women. American women might be pleasantly surprised as they travel abroad.
Originally Posted by texasgoldengirl
and you appear to have interpreted it as a claim that the US is somehow particularly dangerous for women but, by implication, not so much for men. I also don't know of any evidence to support that claim, nor do I think it plausible (for one thing, about 3 times more men are murdered in the US each year than women).
However, when I read her post I did not understand it to be saying anything about the relative danger to women vs men. I thought that she was merely "speaking for herself", i.e., making an assertion based on her particular perspective and personal knowledge/experience, and thus, "As a single female traveling alone in an underground industry...".
In that sense, the statistics I posted do support her, and my, claim that the danger of being a violent crime victim in the US is higher than in most other countries (whether you are a man or a woman). The numbers are pretty dramatic. Look through the table I posted and notice how many countries have homicide rates below 4.44 per 100,000 population per year, i.e., less than *half* that in the US. That factor of two allows for lots of issues, biases and inaccuracies in the individual numbers. Also, check out which countries have rates higher than the 4.44 value and notice that they are not prosperous First World countries like the US; we are way way out of line in that sense too.
Moreover, these numbers *understate* the difference between the US and many other countries for the chance of being murdered "on the street", i.e., as a random innocent victim going about your daily life (or visiting) with no particular risk factors. This is because the totals in the table I posted include both organized crime related murders and domestic violence murders. For the countries with rates down around 1 or 2 or less, these two categories completely dominate the totals and leave virtually no "street violence" murder rate. Japan is an example with which I am relatively familiar. If you can resist the temptation to join the Yakuza (or of going out of your way to give them major grief in some way) and are not one of those unlucky souls with a murderous spouse or family member, you can pretty much forget about the chance that someone will kill you. Compared to the US, you are around
100 times safer in Japan wrt "random" violent crimes.
Anyway, I'd be interested to see any support/evidence for your claim/guess that
I really doubt that the USA is where women have the most to be fearful, quite the opposite I would guess
Originally Posted by WTF
You, of course, identify it as a guess, but why is that your guess...given the very well known and documented high violent crime rate in the US vs other countries?
All this said, I very much agree with you (WTF) that fear of violence is not really justified in a rational or statistical sense, either in the US or the vast majority of other places in the world. People are afraid of whatever dangers get the most media attention, leading to amazing statements like this:
Biggest factor against overseas travel for Americans these days is the risk factor because so many people in so many countries greatly dislike us. Also, the terriorists factor is so great because most Americans overseas look like Americans and tourists and that is like walking around with a bullseye on your back.
Originally Posted by topsgt38801
In reality I'm sure that both terrorism and all other forms of intentional violence are extremely minor risks compared to, say, accidents and illnesses in all but maybe a few of the most violent places on the planet. Fear of violence may keep people from traveling (or foreigners from visiting the US), but it a quite bogus concern when it comes to the actual facts, imo.
-Ww