I don't find that guys with a lot of okays to be hunting for alphabet soup or anything of the type.
Honestly, the guys who have 5 okays have probably been with more than 5 providers.
For me, the more okays the better. I do not care one shred how many women you have slept with - I only care that you treated them with respect, you were clean and safe with them, and you didn't rip them off. That's what okays are FOR. I can learn about you, your preferences, your desires in person.
Just like a lot of guys would probably think twice if we saw 100 reviews for a girl
I disagree, some of the most successful providers have TONS of reviews. They're amazing advertising/web traffic. I can always look at my web stats and tell you exactly what date I got new reviews. That day and 3-4 after my traffic is through the roof. My SSL traffic usually doubles (more people filling out the reservation form).
Now maybe if it was 100 reviews in 5 or 6 months, but 100 reviews over 3-4 years is nothing. I can name providers here and in Canada that I can type in TBD or TER and see at LEAST 100 reviews on either site. I have something like 57 at the moment and I've never had negative effects from them, only compliments on them.