I'm old school. I have worn Obsession for Men for years. It is very subtle - it really can't be experienced unless you are close up to me - and I've never had any complaints.
I have a pretty good selection, maybe 15 different fragrances that I frequently allow the lady to select from herself. The most popular by a large margin has been Jean Paul Gautier, Male. I usually buy off Amazon. About $50
Keep in mind if smells different on one's skin and everyone seems different. I don't really like light blue from D&G however on my skin it smells amazing. Gucci Guilty is decent but I have yet to find anything that smells better than LB on my skin.