WE HAVE TALKED ABOUT THE PRESIDENTS BUT HOW ABOUT THEIR WIVES

Sorry i was sober when I typed that it was just they way you said it. no harm no foul biggest

Rosalind Carter

Betty Ford was pure class!

Stay on topic LM, same thing could be said about Teddy Kennedy. If you cant simply choose your favorite without attacking the others then dont play in this thread. Originally Posted by dirty dog

1. The title of the thread is not about favorites, just wives of presidents.
2. I was on topic.
3. Ted Kennedy was not brought up first by me.
4. I was responding to a post directed at me.

By now they good and the bad first ladies have been covered. So lets move on to non-first lady wives of presidents. Lets start with Ronald Reagan. As you know, Nancy was his second wife. This was his first choice;

"1. The title of the thread is not about favorites, just wives of presidents."

Lame attempt Monger, the introduction post for the thread specified what we are looking for.

"2. I was on topic."

Err no you were not, the thread stated to list the first ladies that you like, it did not ask for you to make disparaging remarks about any of the first ladies.

"3. Ted Kennedy was not brought up first by me."

You are right I brought up Ted Kennedy in reponse to your initial post. Kind of covered under the he who is without sin cast the first stone, I.E. you can't idolize Ted Kennedy but then slam someone else when both killed someone through their neglegence.

"4. I was responding to a post directed at me."

Your initial posting about Laura Bush was not a response to anything anyone posted at you. That was the point in which you were off topic, not the Kennedy response.

And you are still off topic with the latest post, regard Ronnie's first wife. If you would like to discuss it why dont you start your own thread.

DD, LM, please do not argue about what is or is not off topic. If you think something is off topic please send in a RTM.

LM you have been off topic, it is a posting violation and you were warned previously in this thread.

...both killed someone through their neglegence.

Your initial posting about Laura Bush was not a response to anything anyone posted at you. That was the point in which you were off topic, not the Kennedy response. Originally Posted by dirty dog

My initial post about Laura Bush was in response to your first post, where you listed her in your Top 5. You listed her in your Top 5 knowing that she killed someone through her negligence. I was on topic as it was a response to the person that you brought up.

Just as I was on topic when I responded to another person you brought up, Ted Kennedy.

BTW, it appears that Omahan disagrees with you on when I supposedly went off topic.

Furthermore, this is the Sandbox forum. It is an off topic forum.

EDIT: Omahan, you posted at the same time that I did.

thanks omahan you know what I am talking about. on topic well I like ummm no i can't of one sorry