"... would have been ...". I didn't say I actually tried to use them as a reference. I knew all of them were retired except 1 (and she's still active). I did drop some of their names while explaining my situation, trying to build up the sympathy.
But you also just made my point. Guys don't ask for references from older meetings because we want to, but because we don't have much of a choice.
Originally Posted by GoAheadMkMyDay
Put it this way, let's say a provider has had a few reviews then went on a hiatus for a few years. She comes back to provide again, but her reviews are years old. What is the first thing that pops in your mind about her? You could try to PM the hobbyist who saw her last, if he is still around, and see if he remembers her and the session maybe 30+ providers ago, and even if he does, she may have changed drastically since, not only her appearance, but also her style, BCD activities and her approach while BCD.
The same thing can be said of a hobbyist who does the same thing. If you do what I said to do, see a couple of providers at least once every 2 months, then you will not have your choices reduced to only newbie friendly providers. Just because you are a frequent poster on the board does not mean anything as far as how you conduct yourself in person and BCD.
If that was used as a criteria basis for seeing someone, then the opposite must be true as well since given their Eccie board persona, I could think of a few providers you would not see as well many hobbyists who would not be able to see a provider at all, unless he separates his Eccie handle with his P411 handle, probably also changing from his persona from the board, and does not review so that the provider would not be able to tie the two handles together.