Mystic River or The Departed

U hit on the head Goodfellas vs Departed is tough call

Casino vs Goodfellas is tough call

I still pick both over departed. Donnie Brasco is another

The departed is for sure my favorite movie of all time. I have watched more times than I can count.

If you had to choose for an atf list? Originally Posted by thathottnurse

I'd have to go with Infernal Affairs. The original Hong Kong source material that Scorsese based The Departed on.

In answer to the original question, "The Departed" by far.

But while The Departed was excellent, it doesn't come close to Casino or Goodfellas.

They had a screening here in Las Vegas with some of the original players from the Casino story. Fascinating.