Ugh. Just when I think I'm out, they pull me back in.
Jackie was right. My head is spinning. Probably most by this:
"it is also complete and utter folly to EVER make the assumption that ANY verified provider doesn't know every word of any private communication on this board, up to and including the content of PMs that one might (erroneously) believe to be confidential."
And this.
"Nothing here is sacred, and nothing anyone ever writes on A SHMB is EVER private, especially when you surround it with [ PRIVATE ] [ /PRIVATE ] tags or you write it in the Men's Lounge . . . Hell, even if you write it in "staff", it will leak like a sieve."
Originally Posted by TheAdmiral
All true statements, depending on the circumstances . . . Can the material be found online on the "leak" Website whose name we shall (can) not speak? Is it human nature to gossip? Will most ANY gentleman attempt to gain favor by sharing something he believes he shouldn't (and vice versa)? Can a woman buy premium access using a credit card with a man's name on it? Is it possible to copy and forward a PM?
So:
1.) Private messages are not private, and may be accessed by Verified Providers.
2.) The content of postings that are surrounded by PRIVATE tags are not private.
3.) The content of postings in the Men's Lounge is not private.
Originally Posted by TheAdmiral
As for your bullet points, did I
SAY any of those things? I did not, did I?
1.) I don't know, MAY they be? I SUPPOSE that ANYONE might share ANYTHING with ANYONE. Might they? They may! But is access "granted" by default? Not at all . . . . Hence my point, if discretion is observed, most anything CAN be shared with ANYONE - just "understand the worthiness of shutting the fuck up". Just because you CAN say something about something you may know doesn't mean you SHOULD.
2.) I don't know, ARE they? I SUPPOSE that ANYONE might share ANYTHING with ANYONE. Might they? They may! But is access "granted" by default? Not at all . . . . Hence my point, if discretion is observed, most anything CAN be shared with ANYONE - just "understand the worthiness of shutting the fuck up". Just because you CAN say something about something you may know doesn't mean you SHOULD.
3.) I don't know, ARE they? I SUPPOSE that ANYONE might share ANYTHING with ANYONE. Might they? They may! But is access "granted" by default? Not at all . . . . Hence my point, if discretion is observed, most anything CAN be shared with ANYONE - just "understand the worthiness of shutting the fuck up". Just because you CAN say something about something you may know doesn't mean you SHOULD.
Am I the only one who did not know this?!?
Originally Posted by TheAdmiral
I have no idea.
What's the point of PM's, Private tags or the Men's Lounge if any of it is accessible to Verified Providers?!
Originally Posted by TheAdmiral
There isn't any, WHEN PEOPLE CANNOT BE COUNTED ON FOR DISCRETION, hence my point.
I am well and truly amazed. Thank you, Jackie.
Originally Posted by TheAdmiral
Um, okay.
Admiral, you strike me as an intelligent man, don't make me think I gave you more credit than you deserve. The thing is, I know you "get" it, you just can't
play (sell) it, at least not as well as some others. Give it time, I'm sure you'll get there.
Perhaps I should have welcomed you to the
machinations of a SHMB yesterday . . .
Let me make it even easier than how easy I have, which apparently only (further) muddied the grey matter of some . . .
No secret is exempt from being shared. Live your life accordingly. Learn to shut your mouth, and play along. This is true of everything in life, NOT JUST ECCIE.
A line from one of my favorite movies says it best: "You want to learn the first rule you'd know if you'd ever spent a day in your life? You never open your mouth til you know what the shot is. You fucking child."
No one put a gun to Jane's head and made her write what she did, she broke protocol, her indiscretion was blatant and she did it all by and to herself. That someone may have given her the information is immaterial. You don't reveal a confidence.
Any bets on how fast this thread gets closed now?
Marcus: I tired to paint with broad strokes, and even diffuse things a little bit, but some people aren't going to stop until there is "blood spilled for blood spilled".
I can't
MAKE you see that she (Jane) did it to herself, Admiral. Once she committed the indiscretion, she was in a no win situation. No one took her out through "scheming, muckraking and reputation assassination" - most always, it is the same story, they do it to themselves. They don't NEED anyone's help. You've been active here with this username (TheAdmiral) for less than three months, but something tells me this isn't your first rodeo, nor the first time you have gotten yourself kicked off the bull before the bell. Just a gut feeling, maybe I am wrong. If I am, well, my apologies. However, I've never seen (or possibly heard of) the likes of a WK such as yourself in such a "new" member account. Maybe someone should run your IP. LOL
- Jackie