The problem is we will be denying a child's individualism and creativity by sorting out the "workers" from the "thinkers" and basing a child's destiny on the basis of what some government educator thinks is best for the student. It will create a permanent working class, and an aristocracy. Upward mobility will be a thing of the past. You will have your predetermined lot in life established for you as a child.
Sure, certain books were torture. But they were good for you. Reading and analyzing great works of literature are the basis of critical thinking.
Government education has been so dumbed down, it may not even matter at this point, but this is an overt attempt to do what the government has been covertly trying to do for decades. Ignore it if you want. Laugh at me if you want. But this is what's happening. The elites are protecting themselves from you, as well as from me. And the government is blessing their efforts.