Dan Rather lost his position. Williams should too. NBC news can't possibly claim any degree of integrity with him in the position he's in. Originally Posted by boardmanDon't forget what happened to Peter Arnet at CNN.
Dan Rather lost his position. Originally Posted by boardman
Dan Rather lost his position. Williams should too. NBC news can't possibly claim any degree of integrity with him in the position he's in. Originally Posted by boardmanI tend to agree. He should be fired.
During Operation Market Garden (September 17–25, 1944) one of the American correspondents "attached to the 101st was a United Press reporter named Walter Cronkite, who landed by glider. Cronkite recalls that, 'I thought the wheels of a glider were for landing. Imagine my surprise when we skidded along the ground and the wheels came up through the floor. I got another shock. Our helmets, which we all swore were hooked, came flying off on impact and seemed more dangerous than the incoming shells. After landing, I grabbed the first helmet I saw, my trusty musette bag with the Olivetti typewriter inside and began crawling toward the canal which was the rendezvous point. When I looked back, I found half a dozen guys crawling after me. It seems I had grabbed the wrong helmet. The one I wore had two neat stripes down the back indicating I was a lieutenant'" (216-217), A Bridge Too Far, Cornealius Ryan.And there is Ernie Pyle who was killed in the Pacific Theater during the campaign for Okinawa nearly seventy years ago.
IMO .. apples vs. oranges.It may be Apple and Oranges, however, the degree of dishonesty is the same. For NBC news to keep any integrity they need to deal with Williams in a manner that says their integrity is important to them.
I'm not saying Williams shouldn't be taken off the air ... may be shuffling papers or emptying waste paper baskets after rehab ... but
.....Rather was participating in fabrications about another person ... and doing so to have an impact on an election ... and it was further aggravated by the elevated stature he held as a celebrated news personality over the years ... which made his allegations seem that much more credible ... while Williams does not enjoy that "status" in the journalism community that Rather had.
"The higher you are the harder you hit" ... sort of thing. Originally Posted by LexusLover
And there is Ernie Pyle who was killed in the Pacific Theater during the campaign for Okinawa nearly seventy years ago.I never knew that about Cronkite but I always trusted his reporting as the majority of Americans did. I remember watching his final newscast. He signed off like he always did but there was a feeling the evening news wouldn't be the same.
Originally Posted by I B Hankering
I never knew that about Cronkite but I always trusted his reporting as the majority of Americans did. I remember watching his final newscast. He signed off like he always did but there was a feeling the evening news wouldn't be the same.Read Masters Of The Air: America’s Bomber Boys Who Fought the Air War Against Nazi Germany, by Donald L. Miller. It's a history of the Eighth Air Force. Andy Rooney flew missions with some of the aircrews in order to report their stories during WWII.
I remember, as a kid, seeing Peter Jennings hiding behind a bunch of broken concrete with fire and smoke around him and guns and mortars going off in the background noise while reporting from Vietnam. Originally Posted by boardman
[Y]esterday Ernie Pyle came to the end of the road on tiny Ie, some 10,000 miles from his own white cottage and from "That Girl."
In one of his first columns from Africa he had told how he'd sought shelter in a ditch with a frightened Yank when a Stuka dived and strafed, and how he tapped the soldier's shoulder when the Stuka had gone and said, "Whew, that was close, eh?" and the soldier did not answer. He was dead.
“Herr dissected that complex, fraught relationship in a situation where the stakes were mortally high. He thought of himself as the grunts’ brother, sharing their miseries and dangers in the field. On the surface, they seemed to agree. They gave him their helmets and flak jackets, found him mattresses to sleep on, threw blankets over him when he was cold. ‘You’re all right man,’ they said, ‘you got balls.’
“But then would come ‘that bad, bad moment . . . the look that made you look away,’ or the comment of a rifleman watching a jeepload of correspondents drive off: ‘Those fucking guys, I hope they die.’ Then the distance was clear. ‘They weren’t judging me, they weren’t reproaching me, they didn’t even mind me, not in any personal way,’ Herr wrote. ‘They only hated me, hated me the way you’d hate any hopeless fool who would put himself through this thing when he had choices.’ He was not their brother, and he came to a conclusion many reporters prefer not to draw: ‘You were as responsible for everything you saw as you were for everything you did.’ There was only one way to honor that responsibility, and the grunts told him what it was. ‘They would ask you with an emotion whose intensity would shock you to please tell it, because they really did have the feeling that it wasn’t being told for them, that they were going through all this and that somehow no one back in the World knew about it.’" (source)
Albert FallCan I add "John Doe" to the list?
Andrew J Hinshaw
Bernard Kerik
Bill Janklow
Brian J Doyle
Buzz Lukens
Charles R Forbes
Want some more?
Originally Posted by i'va biggen