I agree. I LOVE a gift that is given with LOVE. Yes, I said it, the evil "L" word not allowed in the Hobby...I say BS!
MY friends love to give me gifts they KNOW I LOVE and WANT and WILL USE! Why? Because they care enough to really get to know me, on a level most people are not open to, esp. in the Hobby.
I am SO blessed to know so many truly wonderful people who are happy to go out of their way for me, if needed, as I am for them! This, of course, means they read my profile, reviews, etc., long before they ever contacted me. By the time we finally met in person, we were already friends.
I say, if you're here, I hope you're loving it! If not, why keep doing the same thing without different results?
If more people in the world were open to others, this would not even be a matter of discussion. "Gifts", whether tangible, or not, would be a "given", on both parties. I give ME, every time. I LOVE my life, so there is much to give!