First lets draw a line between legal and illegal immigration. I have no problem with a more robust guest worker program and I think if Democrats and Republicans weren't so locked into their respective corners, this could be easily worked out. With a guest worker program in place we could set the number of entrees to the number needed instead of needing 100,000 in total and getting that every single month at the border.
So if we only needed 100,000 and got 300,000 is that the solution to have 200,000 people in the parking lot of Home Depot looking for day labor? I read that the average level of education is about 6th grade.
The Department of Labor estimates that half of the jobs created in the next five years will require no more than a high school education.
So, what if they don't have a high school education and can't handle these jobs requiring a high school education? And what happens in 10 to 20 years when literally everybody will need specialized training and just having a high school education won't cut it? Have you been in a Burger King or other fast food restaurant lately? A high school education much less a 6th grade education won't help much getting a counter job to take orders when you are met when entering with a computer kiosk to place your order and machines in the make are making the orders.
https://bigthink.com/philip-perry/47-of-jobs-in-the-next-25-years-will-disappear-according-to-oxford-university
47% of jobs will vanish in the next 25 years, say Oxford University researchers
“No government is prepared,” The Economist reports.
But instead of a pro-job growth future, economists across the board predict further losses as AI, robotics, and other technologies continue to be ushered in.
Not only is the entire concept of employment about to change in a dramatic fashion, the trend is irreversible.
By 2034, just a few decades, mid-level jobs will be by and large obsolete.
So what will all these millions of people be doing after the 5 years your article talks about? That's what I'm talking about. We must start working on a plan to only allow those necessary and for only a time necessary.
Losing immigrant labor would be devastating for the U.S. economy
And the opposite could also be true that having to many immigrant laborers un-equipped for the future jobs market could be devastating to our economy.
It comes down to this, how many immigrants is to many? Anybody have an answer to that or is the number un-limited? That we can absorb any number of people that show up at the border. Surely you don't believe that to be true and yet we have near universal agreement among Democrats that everybody that shows up is welcome and they will get free health care, a free education and a guaranteed job even if the job isn't necessary because after all, everybody needs a pay check right?
Originally Posted by HedonistForever
I am talking about LEGAL immigrants.
There will always be a need for unskilled labor. I belong to Gold's Gym and they can't find people to clean the place. I see help wanted signs in hotels, restaurants, Sam's Club, etc. begging for unskilled laborers. We currently have a drastic need for workers in the building trades. Easily learned skills. Yes, some jobs that are now being done by unskilled labor will be replaced but there will always be a need for unskilled labor.
You are predicting a future that will not exist -- one where there is no need for unskilled labor. When I post a link stating that
"The Department of Labor estimates that half of the jobs created in the next five years will require no more than a high school education." you want to speculate on what the people filling those jobs tomorrow be doing after those 5 years. They will still be cleaning the gym, changing sheets in hotels, busing tables in restaurants, doing physical labor in home improvement stores, building homes, etc.
No, we should not allow everyone into this country that wants to enter do so. But we should also not bar everyone who is not educated, does not speak English, and does not have white collar job skills. The strength of our country has always been built by such immigrants.