Proud of President Biden's First two years

adav8s28's Avatar

Would you like to explain why the March 2021 "American Rescue Plan," which squandered about $1.9 trillion more borrowed and printed money, even though the 2020 rescue and stimulus spending was already more than enough to fill the output gap with plenty of room left over, had to "go in?"

What do you progressives think is the primary cause of the high inflation we've seen over the last 12+ months? Originally Posted by Texas Contrarian
TC, I see you have been reading some of my other posts. If you want to debate GM and the TARP assistance they got, you will have to do it in the other thread. There are new rules about staying on topic. I will say this the statement that "Obama gave GM to the unions" is just not true.

1. For your first question you should ask former President Trump why he felt $2000 should go out for the last stimulus he issued instead of $600. Trump is your guy, right?

2. The primary cause for the inflation for the last 12+ months is the supply chain problems caused by the pandemic and Putin invading Ukraine.
TC, I see you have been reading some of my other posts. If you want to debate GM and the TARP assistance they got, you will have to do it in the other thread. There are new rules about staying on topic. I will say this the statement that "Obama gave GM to the unions" is just not true.

Sorry, but I have no interest in further discussing the GM bailout issue with you in this or any other thread, as your responses have demonstrated no intention of even making the most rudimentary effort to comprehend anything I posted.

1. For your first question you should ask former President Trump why he felt $2000 should go out for the last stimulus he issued instead of $600. Trump is your guy, right?

No, he isn't. Although Donald (unlike Joey) at least managed to get a few big picture items right (corporate tax cuts, lightening the regulatory burden, etc.), the debt-accumulation trajectory during his term was unacceptable, even before the onset of the pandemic.

2. The primary cause for the inflation for the last 12+ months is the supply chain problems caused by the pandemic and Putin invading Ukraine.

Nope. Although the supply chain disruptions and the Russia-Ukraine war somewhat exacerbated the inflation problem, the primary driver was clearly the tsunami of excessive relief/stimulus (see below). Originally Posted by adav8s28
As the ginormous $1.9 trillion "American Rescue Plan" was passed in March 2021, even a number of left-leaning economists opined that it was grossly excessive and would result in a surge of inflation. Most notable among them was Larry Summers, who called it the most irresponsible fiscal policy in decades.

Just over a year ago, JPM's analysts reported that household bank balances were about $2.5 trillion more than would have been expected if there had never been a pandemic (or the consequent bailouts and stimulus payments), and if everything had simply remained on its prepandemic trajectory.

So it's plainly the case that even prior to the $1.9 trillion cash tsunami, Americans' household finances had been "made whole" and the output gap had been more than filled.

The $1.9 trillion Inflation Production Plan of March 2021 was simply partisan vote-buying; nothing more.

For those who aren't hyperpartisan progressive zealots, how could any of this be difficult to understand?