I don't think the question is whether the behavior of the kids is exemplary. On the whole, it was not. But it wasn't all that unusual or unexpected when you consider the range of human activity a cop might experience in the line of duty. Some of the kids were very respectful, some where goofing around, some were smart asses. What's new. But when you're a cop, that's what you sign up for -- human behavior in all it's less than perfect forms. You're not getting called to Sunday school picnics.If a peace officer witnesses any felony or breach of the peace, he has a duty to intervene, though pulling the gun looked damn stupid. As for the 15 year old girl, I hear girls are being let into the Ranger training (I suppose at about age 17 or 18?) as well as combat these days. If they want to act tough, they need to feel the other end of the stick.
However good or bad the situation was before hand, it got ten times worse when the asshole cop showed up. The cat fight between the fat white woman and the black gal is unflrtunate, but didn't really amount to a hill of shit in the grand scheme of things. If a cop had witnessed it first hand, I think he'd have been perfectly justified in telling them both to knock it off, separating them, and telling them both to get on they're way. I doubt a good officer would have even written a ticket.
But the cop has to be a calming influence. He can't comed in unhinged rolling around on the ground like Captain Kirk fighting a Klingon. He has to control his emotions no matter what the citizens do. In fact, he especially has to do it when they are ill behaved. Originally Posted by TexTushHog
I've been knocked down and tackled hundreds of times at that age by bigger guys on the football field. I sure as hell knew better than to mouth off at them off the field. If girls think they can do all the tough guy stuff men do then they can't cry like little babies when things get too rough.