Several points here and I will do my best to make them brief
*I believe the OP was making good points about his view on the rest of the story. Learning and voicing some disagreement on how explicit he may want to be. I think this was meant in a discussion manner and some people were helpful in explaining how beneficial it is to the gents to be less vague. However, it started to turn to sour grapes when it became a break down of his hobby budget/dates and if he was a fake or not IMO.
You say he could be any random guy just copying and pasting reviews because he could be some fake (insinuated of course) that doesn't have access to premium access. That doesn't make sense to me. He didn't get access to Premium access til after he started doing reviews and I see where y'all acknowledged because of that he began to improve. So I'm totally confused as to how that makes any sense. Perhaps I read that post wrong and if so I apologize.
To me, he was encouraged to post reviews on the ladies he'd seen. He did. Then y'all began to teach him, in your way, about how important it was to be more detailed. He then got access and improved some. Y'all acknowledged and patted him on the back while encouraging him to get better. But then it became suspect because he had so many to post and several on the same days. Then his credibilty came into question again. Even though Lovely76 and myself have both come forward and verified we have seen him. Which is kind of new for me having to come on here and verify a client publicly, but okay.
Here's where things turned for the worse IMO. . . remember this newbie is new to this board so he doesn't know many, if any, gents at all. One poster says something in a thread that was a joke but it happened to have newbie's name in it. But it was meant as a character from a movie, HUGE coincidence. Problem is this newbie and this poster BOTH have me in common. So what does newbie think? Since this poster saw me after my date with the newbie that I am sharing personal info and he gets upset. Now, for those of us that know poster and know ME know this is bullshit. But for a newbie, I can totally see where this would look suspect.
Here's my point, he is new to THIS board but not the hobby. He is a well established business man and in no way some young, dumb, trust baby. But he is trying to be an active member of the board. Even laughing off some of the pot shots being thrown at him. If he has the funds and time and stamina to play and is doing what he was encouraged to do and learning along the way where is the harm or foul?
Things are not always what they seem. I DID NOT NOR HAVE I EVER disclosed personal information NOR has ANYONE asked me for any personal information on a client EXCEPT for a lady requesting a reference. But it sure could look that way couldn't it? Lesson? . . . Sure could look like he's making these appointments up but he's been verified and the ladies he's reviewed have not said these were false reviews. Should all of the ladies he reviewed come out and verify him? Will it be believable then?
The bummer of it all is that I know both Yssup and Still Looking and think they actually would get along great! Lots of same the great qualities and fun personalities. I think it has just started out on the wrong foot and that really sucks.
I hope things can be brought back into perspective because I believe SL is truly attempting to participate as a positive member but some things have just gone awry.
Sorry, this was longer than I wanted but I wanted to be thorough.