I don't have to many opinions on who has a great ad. I will say that when it is the same ad each week after a while I will just skip it most of the time. So the cut and paste approach is not a good way to get my attention.
I think when you asked:
"Who's are your favorites? Creative, Informative, Short To the Point, Seductive, HOT, Funny, or whatever?!"
YES - all of those. I know it doesn't answer the question but someone taking the time to put some thought and feeling into it usually comes accross better. Use a different picture in each add. Then even if the text is the same we may not even notice!
It does not always have to be long either. I remember seeing an add with just a phone number and said call me as plan B. Short to the point and I knew she would be ok if I did just that. I also got a little chuckle out of it because of its simplicity. Didn't prompt me to see her but I thought it was clever.
As far as Carrie's ad the only improvement I would make would be to add the gopher from Caddyshack instead. Just thinking about him doing a dance in the corner looking at her legs........ "I'm all right, nobody worry 'bout me"
**I tried to add the image of the gopher but it didn't work - I need to go read how to do that. I won't ask since I learned from the other board that search is my friend
**