Perpetual Weight Loss Thread

I think that many of us have an interest in this topic and that a discussion thread would be useful for 'accountabililty' posts as well as tips and techniques, covering both diet and exercise as it pertains to weight loss.

There are lots of different methods out there. I'm hopeful we can be respectful of each other and not get into 'holy wars' about which way is best. The way that is best is the way that lets each one of us lose fat and keep it off. Of course civilized debate and disagreement is fine, and keeping open minds may lead us to methods that work better for us than the ones we have been using.

I just finished reading the book "The Obesity Code" by Dr. Jason Fung, and it's without question the best thing I've ever read about weight loss. I think it makes a strong case for there being other things at play in weight regulation than simply "burn less calories than you consume". There is a big difference in metabolic response (mainly insulin release) between, say, consuming 100 calories of broccoli and 100 calories of Skittles. The book says that too many calories in is the proximate cause of obesity but not the ultimate cause, which has to do with insulin regulation. So, you can definitely reduce weight by addressing the proximate cause (consume fewer calories) but the reason so many people can't keep weight off that they lose is because they are treating the proximate / apparent cause rather than the underlying disorder.

The book is a little "scienc-y" at the beginning and may bore some people but I found it fascinating because it sets the stage for what to do by explaining why it needs to be done. It also is not itself a diet, but a recommendation to change eating patterns (when/how you eat) to get the most metabolic benefit you can. It can be paired with various food plans.

So here's my first accountability post. I figure I need to lose 70 pounds. If I did that I'd be at the high end of what I'd consider an acceptable weight for my height. That would still have me in a BMI range of Overweight but not Obese. In any case it would be a drastic improvement.

The method I'm following is:

  • An Intermittent Fasting Eating Pattern - a bit much to explain here but a good overview is at http://jamesclear.com/the-beginners-...ittent-fasting. It's probably not fasting in the way you'd envision it. I'm using the "LeanGains" 16:8 method meaning a daily 8 hour feeding period and 16 hour fasting period. This seems to be the least extreme of the recommended intermittent fasting methods.
  • A Ketogenic Food Plan - generally less than 20g carbs daily and what carbs are eaten come from vegetables and nuts.
  • HIT (High Intensity Training) Exercise Plan - short bursts of high intensity exercise followed by minimal rest between sets. Weights focusing on large muscle groups: squats, presses, rows, etc. Staring out with as 8 sets of as many reps as can be done in 20 seconds with a 10 second rest period between sets. Also some cardio work in a similar vein - short burts - short rest - short burst, etc. Typically I will do this within the fasting cycle, which challenges conventional wisdom about eating before a workout for energy, but there seems to be some logic in making your body need more energy during a time when glycogen stores are depleted and stored fat needs to be used for energy instead (which it can't be, directly, but if needed can be converted to glucose which is then converted to glycogen for the body to use).
  • Complete avoidance of wheat / grains - This isn't about gluten, exactly, not in the sense that a celiac sufferer would need to avoid it. There is a protein in wheat called giladin that is problematic for weight loss in that it breaks down into peptides that can cross the blood-brain barrier and stimulate appetite. More info at https://wheatbelly.com/. In any case, whether Dr. Davis (the Wheat Belly author) is correct or not, grains are high in carbohydrates and so not compatible with a ketogenic food plan.
I've been doing it for about a week with great results but of course the true test is how it does longer term, and most diets have good short term results, so I'm not even going to post results so far. My results update will be in a month. In the intervening time I'll be going on vacation, which is can be devastating to any weight loss plan, but I hope to at least maintain during that week even if I don't lose any fat during it.
Vannah's Avatar
I've found that I really benefit from making green smoothies in my Nutribullet and drinking one gives me tremendous energy. My favorite one has a spinach/kale mixture, 2 freshly picked peaches, a whole banana, frozen mango chunks and almond milk. To be honest, the fruit really covers up the taste of the green stuff.
I'm going to order this book if it's on Amazon RIGHT NOW. I have lost a great deal of weight since September. No specific plan just couldn't eat regularly that started it and then just ate healthy. I'm planning on having some work done in September and need to lose about 35 more to reach my goal. The first 70+ pounds weren't problem. However this last bit is killing me. I work out, run, swim, have insurmountable amounts of high impact sex lol and it's taking its time coming off. I REFUSE to take diet pills. So I so appreciate you jumping out there Spanky and sharing this information. I've seen something similar to this being advertised on TV. Keep me posted and I will do the same.
I've found that I really benefit from making green smoothies in my Nutribullet and drinking one gives me tremendous energy. My favorite one has a spinach/kale mixture, 2 freshly picked peaches, a whole banana, frozen mango chunks and almond milk. To be honest, the fruit really covers up the taste of the green stuff. Originally Posted by Vannah
Wow that's sounds so good except for the green stuff. I love spinach and make but strictly steamed or in a salad. Does this really kill the taste?? Where do you get frozen mango? Mmmm I want one for dinner lol. You have an awesome body. I adore your taste in bathing suits. I love clothes from that era. So classy and cute.
Dj1981's Avatar
It may be something to look into, road life has def took a toll on my body. I did the p90x thing for about 60 days years ago with great results, but its slowly worked its way back.
It may be something to look into, road life has def took a toll on my body. I did the p90x thing for about 60 days years ago with great results, but its slowly worked its way back. Originally Posted by Dj1981
Sometimes the creeping back is the hardest to keep from happening!!
Sometimes the creeping back is the hardest to keep from happening!! Originally Posted by Sweet Casey
Absolutely. I lost 60 pounds early last year and gained about half of it back. That's one reason I'm so pumped about the Intermittent Fasting part of my current approach, because it gives a framework for not just taking the weight off, but keeping it off.
Good film for those with an interest in avoiding sugar. It's on Amazon Prime Video as of right now.

I've been eating bad food for a few weeks now since I've been on tour with Danielle. I'm on the last leg of the tour in Little Rock through the end of this week. I plan on going home and resuming healthy eating habits, mainly chicken, salmon, eggs & veggies. I also plan to start running the next few weeks before surgery... Should be a lot easier since I just quit smoking!
Rollypolly's Avatar
I started walking again here and seen some benefits but my biggest cause is I don't eat enough. Not enough sounds weird? Cause I only eat 2 meals a day my body slows down burning calories and stores it to burn slowly though the day.
It's said you should be eating 6 times tough the day with small healthy snacks between meals to have your body burning it faster.
I started walking again here and seen some benefits but my biggest cause is I don't eat enough. Not enough sounds weird? Cause I only eat 2 meals a day my body slows down burning calories and stores it to burn slowly though the day.
It's said you should be eating 6 times tough the day with small healthy snacks between meals to have your body burning it faster. Originally Posted by Rollypolly
Rolly, this is indeed the conventional wisdom and there's no doubt some people can lose weight with it. I used to be a pretty ardent supporter of it myself. However for someone with insulin resistance (i.e. a lot of clinically obese people), I'm not sure it will help them to lose fat and keep it off. There is a section in The Obesity Code about it that has given me this doubt.
I think ultimately if you want to lose weight and keep it off, you have to have a complete lifestyle change. I've changed my diet for good: no fast food, no soda and A LOT more veggies and fruit. I don't know if it makes a weight loss difference, but I've been eating simple ingredient foods. No preservatives or weird BS. Only eating foods that I know exactly what each ingredient is. Ive also started a running program called couch to 5K. But strength training has been my main exercise concern. I wanna build muscle. In the past month I've noticed my energy levels are higher, my belly feels better and my brain is clear. It may take me months before I notice a big weight lose, but I'm willing to take my time. I DO NOT want to gain it back.
Rollypolly's Avatar
I think ultimately if you want to lose weight and keep it off, you have to have a complete lifestyle change. I've changed my diet for good: no fast food, no soda and A LOT more veggies and fruit. I don't know if it makes a weight loss difference, but I've been eating simple ingredient foods. No preservatives or weird BS. Only eating foods that I know exactly what each ingredient is. Ive also started a running program called couch to 5K. But strength training has been my main exercise concern. I wanna build muscle. In the past month I've noticed my energy levels are higher, my belly feels better and my brain is clear. It may take me months before I notice a big weight lose, but I'm willing to take my time. I DO NOT want to gain it back. Originally Posted by Lolahhhhh
Congrats, it takes alot of will power to change your lifestyle. I cook alot now to eat healthy. I wish could cut soda and carbs
One of the things that really helped me cut out soda is water flavored with fruit.

I bought one of those large dispensers in the gallon size and cut up fruit and float it in there. I try to drink the entire gallon daily. Of course, traveling it's nearly impossible... I've been drinking the flavorless water bottles. Going to start my cucumber water again as soon as I get home.

I miss my stairmaster, too.

... Ive also started a running program called couch to 5K. Originally Posted by Lolahhhhh
I'm interested in hearing more about this, Lolah!