Yes recommendations

Fellas, here's an idea: if you think a gal you're reviewing didn't earn a "yes" recommendation based on your expectations, don't give her a "yes" thinking someone else would enjoy her company. Giving a yes recommendation when you weren't satisfied leads others to do business with people they might want to avoid and cheapens the value of the yes recommendations earned by some of the great ladies on ECCIE.

If you're worried that giving a bad review will hurt your rep, then your good rep was never that strong. If you're worried about a bad review causing drama, then share the drama with the everyone else so they'll know who to avoid.

End of rant.

When I'm looking for a provider I look at the body of work on the yes/no. So one or even a couple no reviews wouldn't be a dealbreaker. I've yet to write a no review because for one it would take a lot for a provider to get a no, and for two ive always done my homework so hopefully I wouldn't be in that situation in the first place.

So if a reviewer states that he will never return, in your mind Kaos, should he give a yes or a no?

So if a reviewer states that he will never return, in your mind Kaos, should he give a yes or a no? Originally Posted by malwoody

Oh Malwoody, you can think everything is black and white but it is many shades of gray instead.

Just because I don't think a messy room is for me, for some guys it doesn't matter. I have seen one lady several times, and always gave her positive reviews because she rates it. I stopped seeing her because every room, even if she just moved in, was always trashed. Everyone deserves to have the positive mentioned over the negative.

Likewise, everything I have read about Emmie is absolutely great. If I ever get to see her, she certainly wouldn't get a negative review because she is six foot tall and says to in her ads. It would be unfair.

But then, some people just take a joy in being critical.

JR

But then, some people just take a joy in being critical.

JR Originally Posted by JRLawrence

I know exactly what you mean..kind of like accusing someone of making a "public attack" that for some reason has never been found or validated.

You are correct in saying I can be critical, however unlike you I do not criticize statements that were never made or out personal info..

MW

Fellas, here's an idea: if you think a gal you're reviewing didn't earn a "yes" recommendation based on your expectations, don't give her a "yes" thinking someone else would enjoy her company. Giving a yes recommendation when you weren't satisfied leads others to do business with people they might want to avoid and cheapens the value of the yes recommendations earned by some of the great ladies on ECCIE.

If you're worried that giving a bad review will hurt your rep, then your good rep was never that strong. If you're worried about a bad review causing drama, then share the drama with the everyone else so they'll know who to avoid.

End of rant. Originally Posted by CaptainKaos

good point!

It is kinda like giving a restaurant review on YELP...there is nothing worse than getting to a restaurant with rave reviews,to find out is sucks! I believe honesty will help business more...If I were to get a bad review,it would show me what aspects of my business I would need to improve on!

good point!

It is kinda like giving a restaurant review on YELP...there is nothing worse than getting to a restaurant with rave reviews,to find out is sucks! I believe honesty will help business more...If I were to get a bad review,it would show me what aspects of my business I would need to improve on! Originally Posted by DallasRain

the point has been made before
but it's still correct
the key to a yes or no is WHY

If I write NO
then explain, "I don't like how she used her tongue to try to go up my urethra!
some guys might want to see a gal who has such a flexible tongue

lol I luv that pic babe!

*Pic removed - JCM

I just noticed a "super moderator" on here has 11 pages of reviews.....eleven pages of reviews. Each and everyone of them a yes. Dude has impeccable luck, he should live at a casino.

So if a reviewer states that he will never return, in your mind Kaos, should he give a yes or a no? Originally Posted by malwoody

I'd say that's a no. The reviewer has no idea what I like, so how can he possibly recommend a service to me or anyone else. A review is a first-person account, so the recommendation needs to be from the first person's POV.

Everyone deserves to have the positive mentioned over the negative.
JR Originally Posted by JRLawrence

Don't you think the people who rely on your reviews deserve the truth? If you don't like a messy room to the point it's a deal breaker, them that means you wouldn't recommend that provider to yourself. I you wouldn't recommend something to yourself, how could you possibly recommend it to a stranger?

Dudes complain about shitty service and other dudes jump on them to "do their research". Well what good is it if the research is bogus? This site is designed to reward to performers and weed out the ones that might want to consider other forms of employment. When you give a yes recommendation to someone who doesn't deserve it, you cheapen the value of the yes recommendation for the girl who worked her tail off. And doesn't she deserve more than the girl who didn't?

So if a reviewer states that he will never return, in your mind Kaos, should he give a yes or a no? Originally Posted by malwoody

You need more details to decide

the key to a yes or no is WHY

If I write NO
then explain, "I don't like how she used her tongue to try to go up my urethra!
some guys might want to see a gal who has such a flexible tongue Originally Posted by bigcockpussylicker

Maybe there needs to be another option other than a straight YES or NO. To me a No is warranted for a few reasons such as hygiene, poor performance, poor attitude not delivering as advertised.

If the provider ends up as a blonde bimbo with no smarts and I like a girl with some intelligence, I won't see her again. But she lived up to all as advertised, does that warrant a NO?

you can alwasy state YMMV