Don’t judge a man by his number of reviews

I just want to put this out there. Just because a guy doesn’t always do a review doesn’t necessarily mean he is new to the game. It seems like the guys with a large number of reviews are more highly respected than the ones with-let’s say 5 reviews. I have been playing this game for 20 years and have seen a lot of ladies and been through a lot of BS along the way. I will do a review if (1) I am asked to (2) I feel I need to warn the community of a bad experience (3) to keep my premium access alive on here. It’s similar to Amazon... if the customer is happy he probably won’t say anything but if he got a bad product or bad service-time to tell the world. Also, I feel like if I have a great experience, it seems a little UN-gentlemanly to describe in detail what was done BCD. After all, if it was truly a GFE.. I don’t tell anyone what I did with my GF. That’s just my opinion. Of course this is all fun and games but I still want to keep some secrets.
I understand that good reviews help a provider (especially if she’s new). But if a provider already has 100 reviews-what difference is one more going to make?

I agree with you on one thing...just because you are new to the boards, does not mean you are new to the hobby. And, if you thought about it, on Eccie, if they took out the fake reviews (usually done for PA) and the pimp ad promo reviews (which are also fake), the review count would be considerably less. I know a few guys with triple digit review counts that if all the shill reviews were taken out of their review count, they would probably have it reduced to single digits.

However, this is an info share board, you are not obligated to share all or any of your experiences ( I wouldn't call it un-gentlemanly if you did a review and neither would the provider you saw for a session to review your good experiences with her). No one likes a guy who takes from the board and does not give back. Providers are not on the internet and placing ads to be kept a secret, so review them. Plus, not reviewing a provider means that your opinion on her BCD skills is irrelevant.

Some thoughts on this...

Not sure if I agree it’s “un-gentlemanly” to describe your experience with a Provider here. I certainly don’t consider reviewing my experiences as un-gentlemanly and sharing info is what this board is about.

Even if a Provider has 100 reviews, maybe something changed since the last few: rates, activities, her looks, etc. I only read the last 4 or 5 anyway to see the latest info on her. I might be a little leery if she has 100 and her last one was 6 months ago.

I’m glad you feel the need to write a review based on a lousy or dangerous encounter, but that shouldn’t be the only reason to write them. I haven’t seen your reviews but if you have more negative than positive reviews, the girls might be cautious to see you based on that. I know I would. You also don’t need to warn others of a dangerous Provider via a review; post about it in other forums.

Any contribution here, good or bad is welcomed.
And...bad info on a girl isn’t necessarily more reliable or truthful than good info.

I struggle to post reviews using my phone, so I just don’t review....that said, I’m awesome in the sack. I cum everytime. Sometimes twice. Once three times...

I struggle to post reviews using my phone, so I just don’t review....that said, I’m awesome in the sack. I cum everytime. Sometimes twice. Once three times... Originally Posted by 2929BN

I do my reviews on my phone too and it can be a challenge. Keep in mind, we are reading the reviews to learn how the provider performed/looked not what a stud you were.

100% agree with WEC and the thread. I feel the whole idea of reviews is to describe the overall experience, the provider, TCB, IOP but most reviews seem to be a testament to the male prowess of the OP .. sound as if they are gift to womankind..
There seems to be an unspoken order in the board where based on # of posts or reviews, you get a cabinet post and then there are the valued posters who lay it out like it is. So it's a roll of dice with the reviews imho.

As WEC said if we take out the fluff reviews for PA/review specials (which usually tend to be good for obvious reasons) or return favors, I have oft relied on some to make a decision to meet and have not had bad experiences for the most part when relying on reviews by valued posters.

I think the last time I logged in on the PC to this site was when I registered... That’s a long time ago 🤔💭

You guys can still post reviews and post via phone or tablet it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to do so.

As for the “UN-gentlemanly” part I have to disagree you don’t have to be full detail unless you want to. I like most just really look at location, customer service from the provider, looks compare to showcase, and overall experience. Everything else is fluff in my opinion which I have time I will read if not I’ll just scan the review for what I find useful.

The issue may be stemming from the detail you may put or your reviews compare to the number of reviews

Just my 2¢

I agree with you on one thing...just because you are new to the boards, does not mean you are new to the hobby. And, if you thought about it, on Eccie, if they took out the fake reviews (usually done for PA) and the pimp ad promo reviews (which are also fake), the review count would be considerably less. Originally Posted by Wile E Coyote

exactly.. I don't know the extent of fake reviews, but there are MANY. some for PA, some for pure promotion. what is sorely needed is accurate, and more reviews. which is why I'm perplexed when guys like the OP post. sure, not every guy has to review every time, there are other ways to contribute. but at its core, this Site is based on reviews. every day I see guys who post "I saw XXX yesterday, she was great".. I ask them to write a review, or they post "review coming"... then no review is ever posted. that tells me the guy NEVER saw the lady, he is a Promoter/second handle who is bullshitting. then you have those who post "I saw XXX, she was horrible".. no review.. that tells me that handle is a Troll, who wants to destroy the business of the lady in question.

I have reviewed all but about 5 ladies I have seen. I love to write reviews, and think of them as a personal journal entry.. my writing style is narrative, so I can re-live the whole experience. if the Board gets anything from it, that is a bonus.

I struggle to post reviews using my phone, so I just don’t review....that said, I’m awesome in the sack. I cum everytime. Sometimes twice. Once three times... Originally Posted by 2929BN

you are awesome

As for the “UN-gentlemanly” part I have to disagree you don’t have to be full detail unless you want to. Originally Posted by fozziewockabear

agree.. write something.. just be factual. if the non-Promoters don't write reviews, the second handles and Promoters will take your place, and the Board will suffer.

OP, are you getting flak from providers because of your review count? If you are, it may be due to the ratio of no:yes recommendations more so than the actual count. Ladies will often look at your posting and review history, and if they perceive you are a “finicky eater” they may not want to see you.

My apologies if I’m off base in how I’m reading between the lines of what you posted. It just struck me as a likely source of frustration. If I’m on to something with my analysis, you might try posting some more of your positive experiences to balance out the perception.

OP, as somebody who used to play in the desert that is east tx, I can attest, there's not much out there. It requires more research and time to go down the rabbit hole. I've had some no reviews out that way myself. https://www.eccie.net/showthread.php?t=1713479

https://www.eccie.net/showthread.php?t=1749686

https://www.eccie.net/showthread.php?t=1796565

Just a small sample. You have to do some digging to find the girls out that way. Good luck OP, and hopefully your fortunes improve

OP, as somebody who used to play in the desert that is east tx, I can attest, there's not much out there. It requires more research and time to go down the rabbit hole. I've had some no reviews out that way myself. Originally Posted by mrredcat43

I have been down a few “rabbit holes” myself and what I found was not as soft and fluffy as a rabbit. (Although the last “rabbit hole” I went down I found a lady with a bush that would shame most respectable rabbits-or wolverines)
I end up traveling to Big D to find the real gems. Sometimes the hunt out here “in the desert” is fun but often it turns out to be a waste of time and resources. Believe it or not, I have refrained from leaving some “no” reviews because from the reviews I read, everyone else seemed to see a different woman than the one I saw. Maybe I am a “picky eater” ... or at least want to know what the other guys were drinking when he saw her so I can drink some too. I don’t mind seeing someone who isn’t a 10, I just hate expecting an 8 (based on reviews) and finding a 4.

I do look at past reviews as a part of my screening process. If I see several NO's I think one or two things....

1.) You are likely going to be hard to please.

2.) You make very bad decisions when choosing providers.

Either way, most of us don't want to be your next "NO". I can certainly understand that some remote areas don't have the selection of providers that DFW does.

Since I do this by phone, it gets cumbersome to write a good review. So most encounters I don’t do reviews on. That or I’m busy and enough shiny objects come my way and I end up forgetting to do it.

I struggle to post reviews using my phone, so I just don’t review....that said, I’m awesome in the sack. I cum everytime. Sometimes twice. Once three times... Originally Posted by 2929BN

Words to live by. You are my new idol

Over the past 12 months I have hooked up with a number of popular ECCIE ladies and when I ask if they would like a review the answer is ....up to you but it's really not necessary as I have plenty...Mia Milan comes to mind. Like one poster said sometimes guys use the review just to show off their sexual prowess.