A threesome with another guy wouldn't bother me "too" much, provided that no homo stuff is involved, and she does NOT develop feelings for the other guy. But what's got me thinking is why does she wanna do it with an Ex? She makes me think that she still has feelings for this guy. Once I agreed to it, she had him on the phone within hours asking if he wanted to do it. I'm cool with maybe a one time deal, but if she wants to start fucking this dude all the time now, I'm not so sure about that, unless I had a side chick that we did threesomes with on a regular basis, so we can "even the playing field" so to speak.
Originally Posted by EastBeast504
The issue with the Ex could be several possibilities.
1. It might just be that it's someone she is familiar and comfortable with. It's is simply easier to talk yourself into having sex with someone that you've already had sex with before.
2. It might be that she knew that this is something that he would be okay with.
3. She might still harbor feelings for him as you're already concerned about.
4. All of the above.
I wouldn't worry too much about number 3. Sure, it is possible. But if she were secretly still carrying a torch for this dude she probably wouldn't want to bring him into an MMF experience with you. She would be much more likely to hide that. If it is really something you're worried about sit down with her and have an open and candid conversation with her about it. It is also important to remember that whatever there may have been between the two of them in the past, there is a reason that she is with you now and not him.
I've never been in your exact situation. But I do have an Ex who is now married to another dude and they live in another state. She has expressed interest in having sex with me again and he has said that he is okay with it (she took a screenshot of them texting each other about me having sex with her and sent me the screenshot to prove to me that he was okay with it. Sounds strange, I know but that's just my life... one long strange trip). So there might be something similar happening in my future. Who knows?
On the issue of choosing a provider or letting her know what you've been up to in the past, I'd suggest walking a bit more softly here. Admit to nothing until you're sure that she is cool with it. Maybe suggest it as a possibility that you've heard of.
Say that "your friend Sketch knows this girl Destiny" for example. (I really don't... yet. But she is on my list) Or something along those lines.
The most important thing there really though is that you should let her choose the girl. At least the first time that this happens. You can talk to her about the types of girls that you like or whatever but in the end, she should be the one who chooses the girl. Just my opinion but here is why. She'll be more comfortable with it if she has control of the decision. She will also be less likely to get upset at you for wanting to fuck another girl. It isn't just about you, it's about her too. In fact, if I were you I'd make it mostly about her as much as possible.
Those are just my thoughts.
And on a side note... If the two of you ever want a complete and total stranger in your MMF scenario, hit me up.