I prefer the freshly-showered scent of men's body wash. I think cologne is a little too much sometimes, and I love the fresher smell of matching body wash & deodorant. It doesn't really matter which one as long as it is not Brut or Hi Karate (do they still make that?!).
Anything by Axe is pretty
RAWR!
Surprisingly, Old Spice has a really nice collection now. Nothing like what it was in the 70's-80's. I LOVE the scent of Old Spice "Swagger" body wash. Wash the boys in that after round one with me, if you are an MSOG guy. I'll be a happy lady down there, and you will be happier than me
.
If I had a gun to my head and had to pick a cologne, it would be Chanel Allure for men or Armani's Aqua Di Gio.