review by provider/female?

On the main board there is this thread http://www.eccie.net/showthread.php?t=62174 a provider asking how to post a review. In the Another Realm http://www.eccie.net/showthread.php?t=30354a review by a provider. And she is listed as having a review.

Is Another realm the only place a provider can post a review? Where can a provider post a review, then can she post a link in lets say co-ed to help us find it if she can not review in a review forum?

hehehe opps jack is still in the house

I know of at least One provider that is also a Hobbiest, I would encourage the board to allow her to post a review of her date

I agree, but we have already been shot down on this subject.

I think it had to do with the fact that the woman doing the review was not a provider in this case.

Read the 2nd linked thread again. I think she is a provider. But I would add the the review count dos not say you got credit for review. Just that you did one. And it was month or two before it came up in upstate ny.

Posted by John Bull Moderator in that thread as follows:

Providers are not permitted to post reviews in review areas. Another Realm is not a review area so that may be in review format but isn't considered a review and would get no review credit.
Hope this helps.
__________________
Cheerio

John Bull
========================

The one problem I can see allowing providers to post reviews is that gives them access to the rest of the story which in some cases I don't think that is such a good idea.

The one problem I can see allowing providers to post reviews is that gives them access to the rest of the story which in some cases I don't think that is such a good idea. Originally Posted by jymie

Good point, but can't people be denied BCD credit for a review if it doesn't fit certain criteria? So allow them to review, but deny them the credit.

Not that i care one way or the other. Just thought i would bring up the point.

That would work for verified providers. In a case where a provider has yet to become verified, does a review, then gets credit, then provider becomes verified later. Some screen names you would have a hard time differenciating male from female. I am sure it would be to hard to keep that separate. Of course when we all sign up on this site we say that we are males or females so, I am thinking that it is built into the system to not allow females to do reviews.

Read the 2nd linked thread again. I think she is a provider.

OSD, I did get that she was a provider, I thought because she was not verified on this site it made a difference. I see from subsequent posts that it does not. Thanks.

How about, if she was a man transgendered to a woman, and then decided she was Bi or lesbian.....? Never mind....

I have to chime in on this! I have personally gone through this a while back when I was trying to gain more of a perspective on wht the guys go through setting up and doing an appointment. I picked a girl I had never heard of and from a city I had never provided in (at the time) and only had a showcase and reviews to go on. I was given the go ahead to write the review if I paid for and had a legitimate appointment.

I did that. I saw christinadoll in Buffalo the very first trip out. I spent a while writing a review and then was shot down when I tried to post. I had NO desire to have BCD access because that is YOUR place to talk NOT mine. I no desire for credit either. I just wanted to write it and post it and what I privately wrote to be BCD for only the guys to read.

I have since (before my temporary agency) saw Mary. She was a duo gift for my ex that drove from Boston to ex-ray my toe (being a bone specialist) to make sure I had no floating fragments.

I also enjoyed an appointment with Gia (before our duos). Gave up my donation to have her join as a gift to a beloved client.

I would have to say I am a small time hobbiest with a bit of penis envy lol. I will continue to hobby as I provide and maybe after as well.

Jymie I wish I knew about Another Realm when I tried to post a review!! And by the way is it Jimmie or Jamie penunciation wise . . .

hope I have not upset anyone by bring this up again. Thinking of remix's 2nd post It is hard to know how this all went down after the fact. And he may be right. Or just did it. And it was moved to Another Realm. Also I hope I have not upset Chloe most of all. And others also.

is it Jimmie or Jamie penunciation wise . . . Originally Posted by Chloe

It is pronounced jamie.

I was amazed by this policy on ASPD and I'm still amazed. Girls offer to post detailed descriptions of girl-on-girl and we turn them down?

It boggles the mind.