new McCarthyism: racist firings/resignations

dilbert firestorm's Avatar
https://www.thedailybeast.com/everyo...nderpump-rules


Everyone Who’s Lost Their Job During the Racism Reckoning of 2020

From The New York Times and CrossFit to the L.A. Galaxy and ‘Vanderpump Rules,’ people are losing their jobs over racist or racially insensitive behavior. Here are all of them.

Tarpley Hitt
Reporter

Updated Jun. 12, 2020 7:00PM ET / Published Jun. 10, 2020 4:15AM ET

In the days after George Floyd’s tragic death, protests erupted in over 350 American cities, the National Guard was deployed to 23 states, and more than 14 metro areas implemented curfews. For more than two weeks, protesters have taken to the streets, sometimes several times per day, demanding justice for Floyd’s family, police defunding, and a comprehensive reimagination of public safety. But as the civil unrest played out in public, it has also migrated into the workplace.

In the past 15 days, workers at media institutions, sports franchises, TV shows and food chains, as well as online critics, have forced companies and corporations to confront charges of racism, overhaul their hiring practices, and interrogate how places from The New York Times and CrossFit to the grocery store Holy Land might find ways for reform. More than once, this has led to oustings and resignations.

Here are all of them so far. (This story will be updated as more developments follow.)

Person: Audrey Gelman
Job: Founder of The Wing
Date: June 11, 2020
Reason: After a virtual strike from staff, the founder of the millennial pink women’s co-working space, The Wing, stepped down Thursday. In recent months, the company had weathered several criticisms pointing to the disparities between its supposed ethos of inclusion, its overwhelmingly white membership, and the underpaid workers who ran the physical spaces, who were largely people of color. “In solidarity with so many of our colleagues—past, present, and in particular, the black and brown people without whom The Wing would not exist—as a united group of employees, we are participating in a virtual walkout beginning today,” staff wrote in a statement before their Thursday walkout. “I’m looking forward to spending a little time as a stay-at-home mom,” Gelman told The New York Times Thursday.

Person: Leandra Medine
Job: Founder/Editor-in-Chief of Man Repeller
Date: June 10, 2020
Reason: After publishing a blog post titled, “Where We Go From Here: A Message for the MR Community,” claiming the website “will not remain silent in the face of police brutality and white supremacy,” the Man Repeller founder faced criticism online for its lack of diversity and general outlook.

In a statement on Instagram Wednesday night, Cohen announced she would be “stepping back” from operations, but did not specify what exactly that would look like. “The team deserves a chance to show you what Man Repeller can be with me on the sidelines,” Cohen wrote, “so I’m going to step back and let them show you.”

Person: Greg Glassman
Job: Founder/CEO of CrossFit
Date: June 9, 2020
Reason: Last week, on a phone call with several CrossFit gym owners, the WOD designer Greg Glassman told a Minneapolis affiliate: “We’re not mourning for George Floyd—I don’t think me or any of my staff are. Can you tell me why I should mourn for him? Other than that it’s the ‘white’ thing to do—other than that, give me another reason.”

The conference call pushed several owners, who run largely autonomous businesses which license the CrossFit name and method, to disaffiliate from the company. On Tuesday night, the company released a statement from Glassman announcing he had “decided to retire.”

Person: Wendy Melsey
Job: Host of The Weekly with Wendy Mesley on the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation
Date: June 9, 2020
Reason: In preparation for an episode on Black Lives Matter and racism coverage in the media, Mesley “used a word that should never be used.” In a statement given to the podcast Canadaland, Mesley elaborated: “In the context of an editorial discussion about current issues regarding race, I used a word that should never be used... It was not aimed at anyone, I was quoting a journalist we were intending to interview on a panel discussion about coverage of racial inequality.”

A CBC spokesperson told Canadaland that Mesley had been removed from her position, pending an investigation into the incident. Mesley reportedly apologized to her co-workers “immediately,” adding, “I was careless with my language and wrong to say it. Regardless of my intention, I hurt people and for that I am very sorry. I am also deeply ashamed.”

People: Stassi Schroeder, Kristen Doute, Max Boyens, and Brett Caprioni
Job: Vanderpump Rules cast members
Date: June 9, 2020
Reason: A spokesperson for Bravo told Variety that Schroeder and Doute, along with two new cast members, Boyens and Caprioni, would not be returning to the reality series following racist incidents. Last week, fellow cast member Faith Stowers claimed in an Instagram Live that, in 2018, Schroeder and Doute had called the police on her following the publication of a Daily Mail article about a black woman wanted for robbery. Schroeder and Doute allegedly told authorities that Stowers was the wanted woman, though the person pictured did not resemble her at all.

Boyens and Caprioni will also not return to the show after fans unearthed racist tweets after the new season premiered in January. The pair initially apologized, but after outlets revisited the incident last week, both were let go.

Person: Adam Rapoport
Job: Editor-in-Chief of Bon Appétit
Date: June 8, 2020
Reason: On June 6, freelance food writer Illyanna Maisonet shared screenshots of Instagram DMs with Rapoport about why the magazine passed on a pitch about Puerto Rican cuisine. Three days later, fellow food writer Tammie Teclemariam tweeted a photo of Rapoport in Puerto Rican brown face. The photo, taken at a costume party in 2013, with the caption, “I do not know why Adam Rapoport simply doesn’t write about Puerto Rican food for @bonAppétit himself!!!” had come from Rapoport’s wife’s Instagram, where she called him “papi” and used the Puerto Rican hashtag #boricua, which refers to the name given to the island by its indigenous people, the Taino.

In the hours after the picture emerged, other Bon Appétit writers and former staff posted about discrimination at the magazine. Sohla El-Waylly, an assistant editor who frequently stars in Bon Appétit’s popular test kitchen videos, claimed in an Instagram story that, while white editors are paid for their appearances, people of color are not. The statement prompted white Bon Appétit editors to announce a boycott of the videos until the payment structure was reformed. Later that afternoon, Rapoport announced on Instagram that he would be stepping down as EIC to “reflect on the work that I need to do as a human being and to allow Bon Appétit to get to a better place.”

Person: Christene Barberich
Job: Top Editor and Co-Founder of Refinery29
Date: June 8, 2020
Reason: After several Refinery29 writers and freelancers wrote on social media about discrimination at the Vice-owned fashion outlet, top editor Christene Barberich stepped down on Monday. One of the writers, Ashley C. Ford, wrote on Twitter, “I worked at Refinery29 for less than nine months due to a toxic company culture where white women’s egos ruled the near nonexistent editorial processes. One of the founders consistently confused myself and one of our full-time front desk associates & pay disparity was atrocious.”

Barberich announced her resignation in an Instagram post. “I’d like to start by saying that I’ve read and taken in the raw and personal accounts of Black women and women of color regarding their experiences inside our company at Refinery29,” she wrote in the caption. “And, what's clear from these experiences, is that R29 has to change. We have to do better, and that starts with making room.

And, so I will be stepping aside in my role at R29 to help diversify our leadership in editorial and ensure this brand and the people it touches can spark a new defining chapter.”

I am ashamed I was capable of these really horrible attempts to get attention at that time. I regret them deeply.

Person: Hartley Sawyer
Job: Actor in The Flash
Date: June 8, 2020
Reason: Hartley Sawyer, who played Ralph Dibny, aka “Elongated Man,” on The CW series The Flash, was fired Monday after Twitter users found tweets making light of racism and sexual assault. Sawyer’s Twitter account has since been deleted, but according to The Hollywood Reporter, in 2012 he allegedly wrote, “The only thing keeping me from doing mildly racist tweets is the knowledge that Al Sharpton would never stop complaining about me.” Elsewhere, he wrote, somewhat incoherently, “Date rape myself so I don’t have to masturbate.”

A statement from The CW announced that Sawyer would not be returning for the show’s seventh season, adding “In regards to Mr. Sawyer’s posts on social media, we do not tolerate derogatory remarks that target any race, ethnicity, national origin, gender, or sexual orientation.” Sawyer apologized on Instagram: “I am ashamed I was capable of these really horrible attempts to get attention at that time. I regret them deeply.”

Person: James Bennet
Job: Editorial Page Editor of The New York Times
Date: June 7, 2020
Reason: Bennet resigned Sunday after the newspaper ran a widely criticized opinion piece from Senator Tom Cotton (R-AR), encouraging the use of military force against protesters. The piece, which ran under the headline “Send In the Troops,” called for “an overwhelming show of force to disperse, detain and ultimately deter lawbreakers.”

After it ran, dozens of journalists at The New York Times spoke out on social media, in a rare break from company policy, accusing the paper of lending a platform to fascism and endangering their black staff. Freelance writers posted screenshots of emails retracting their pieces; others donated their most recent checks to protest-related funds. In private conversations, Bennet later admitted that he had not even read the op-ed before it ran.

Person: Stan Wischnowski
Job: Top Editor of The Philadelphia Inquirer
Date: June 6, 2020
Reason: On June 1, Philadelphia Inquirer architecture columnist Inga Saffron, a Pulitzer Prize winner, wrote a column asking, “Does the destruction of buildings matter when black Americans are being brazenly murdered in cold blood by police and vigilantes?” The column took a look at the future of Philadelphia architecture after the protests. It ran under the headline: “Buildings Matter, Too.” On June 3, 44 journalists of color signed an open letter to the paper’s management calling for change, and announcing a virtual “sick out” the following day in protest. The paper changed the headline and issued an apology, adding that the headlines are usually written by one editor and approved by a second. The headline had followed that process, they wrote, but did not specify who had approved it. On Saturday, top editor Stan Wischnowski tendered his resignation. (Disclosure: I worked at The Inquirer in 2017).

Person: Aleksandar Katai
Job: Midfielder on the L.A. Galaxy
Date: June 5, 2020
Reason: On June 3, the Los Angeles soccer team became aware that Tea Katai, the wife of midfielder Aleksandar Katai, had shared memes mocking the past week’s protests. In one post, she captioned a screenshot of police driving through protesters in New York last week with a Serbian phrase that translates to “kill the shits.” The second showed a protester holding a red Nike shoe box with the caption “Black Nikes Matter.”

Later that day, the team released a statement condemning the posts, and announcing a meeting to discuss Katai’s next steps. They decided to release him the morning after the meeting. “The decision, in that respect, was not a difficult one,” team president Chris Klein told the L.A. Times. “We have to hold to those values. This is not a soccer decision.”

Person: Andrew Alexander
Job: CEO of Second City
Date: June 5, 2020
Reason: Amid allegations that he had helped foster a culture of racism at the Chicago improv institution, Alexander posted a long letter to the theater’s website, announcing his resignation. “The Second City cannot begin to call itself anti-racist,” Alexander wrote. “That is one of the great failures of my life.” The outcry came after Second City tweeted in support of Black Lives Matter on May 31, prompting bemused and outraged posts from Black comedians who had endured discrimination while performing there. Among them: Space Force writer Aasia LaShay claimed that, after reporting an assault from a white cast member, they told her she “had to find a way to still perform with him,” prompting her to quit.

Person: Holy Land CEO’s daughter Lianne Wadi
Job: Catering Director at Holy Land
Date: June 4, 2020
Reason: In one of the wilder developments, the CEO of the Minneapolis food company, Holy Land, Majdi Wadi announced in a Facebook post on June 4 that the company had fired an employee for posting “racial slurs on social media.” The employee, it turned out, was Wadi’s daughter, Lianne Wadi. That morning, Lianne shared an apology on Instagram, saying she was “deeply mortified and disgusted by the comments,” which she made as “a teenager.” But as City Pages reported, internet sleuths uncovered tweets belonging to a Twitter account @LianneWadi, which has since been deleted, that disparaged Black, Jewish, fat, and gay people. It was also “pro-Hitler.”

In one tweet, the account wrote of her family, “My dad& workers: at least were not n*****s #classic.” In another, it tweeted, “Anything involving the n****r we call our president (;.” The same account also retweeted a user posing as Hitler, @TrueAdolphHitler,” who posted things like, “Holy shit. I just realized Blacks are just as bad as Jews. #GasEmAll.” The @LianneWadi account commented “I’ve always known!!”

People: Kimberly Ray & Barry Beck
Jobs: Radio hosts on Radio 95.1 FM, owned by iHeartMedia
Date: June 3, 2020
Reason: On Tuesday, June 2, the popular radio duo aired a discussion about a conflict between protesters and two counter-protesters that resulted in the assault of a local woman. In the conversation, Ray asked whether the attackers had acted “n-word-ish” and “n-word-ly.”

She never actually said the “n-word,” but used the euphemism three times during the segment. “OK, let me ask you a question. Were they acting n-word-ish?” Ray asked at one point. They went on to question why they couldn’t use the word itself. “No one’s offended by that,” the pair determined. The following morning, Robert J. Morgan, iHeartMedia’s New York regional president, confirmed with the Rochester Democrat and Chronicle that the pair had been terminated.

Person: Craig Gore
Job: TV writer for NBC’s Law & Order: Organized Crime
Date: June 2, 2020
Reason: Gore, who also wrote for Chicago P.D. and S.W.A.T., was fired from Dick Wolf’s Law & Order spinoff series last week after threatening violence against protesters on social media. In one, Gore posted a picture of himself with a gun, captioned “Curfew…” on Facebook. In a comment below, he wrote, “Sunset is being looted two blocks from me,” referring to the famous L.A. boulevard, adding, “You think I won’t light motherfuckers up who are trying to fuck w/ my property I worked all my life for? Think again....”

In a statement on Tuesday, Wolf wrote, “I will not tolerate this conduct, especially during our hour of national grief. I am terminating Craig Gore immediately.”

Person: Grant Napear
Job: Sacramento Kings TV broadcaster for KTHK Sports 1140
Date: June 2, 2020
Reason: Napear, a 60-year-old radio broadcaster who co-hosted an AM radio show with former Kings player Doug Christie, resigned on Tuesday after posting an anti-protest tweet. The previous Sunday, DeMarcus Cousins, who played for the Kings for over six seasons before getting traded to New Orleans and whom Napear frequently criticized, tweeted at the host, “What’s your take on BLM?”

Napear responded: “Hey!!!! How are you? Thought you forgot about me. Haven’t heard from you in years. ALL LIVES MATTER...EVERY SINGLE ONE!!!” Cousins wrote back, “Lol as expected.” Former Kings forward Matt Barnes weighed in: “Would expect nothing less from a closet racist.” Napear later apologized, calling his comments “dumb.” He was fired Tuesday morning.

Person: Amy Cooper
Job: Franklin Templeton
Date: May 26, 2020
Reason: After Cooper went viral over a video in which she threatened to call the cops on Black birdwatcher Christian Cooper (no relation), and feign fear for her life, Cooper was fired from asset management firm Franklin Templeton. The company claimed in a statement on May 26 that they “do not tolerate racism of any kind.”



Tarpley Hitt
Reporter

Tarpley.Hitt@thedailybeast.com

Got a tip? Send it to The Daily Beast here.
  • oeb11
  • 06-16-2020, 09:06 AM
Looks like the Lib DPST's have now been successful in framing the national debate to a Us virtuous - repulican Conservatives "Racist".

And the LSM is having a great time persecuting anyone with a non-socialist opinion.



It is getting dangerous - with the Seattle situation - where the LDM fawns over terrorist -anarchsit -revolutionaries who appropriated the police station and other's properties and homes and belongings.

They are fomenting civil War - I suggest u arm yourelves before the Socialists repeal the Cosntitution and come for all who have ever disagreed, or might disagree.


socialist revolutions - Castro, chavez/maduro - and others - always begin their rule with bloody Walls.

and - many of the LSM sycophants will be among the chosen for trip to the wall - to their horror.

socialists will not tolerate anything other than a media devoted totally to socialist propaganda.
HedonistForever's Avatar
"Did you speak up when they came for".......... is getting a new 21st century test and "we" seem to be failing.
  • oeb11
  • 06-16-2020, 11:22 AM
Amen., HF
the_real_Barleycorn's Avatar
Before McCarthy there was Marx. Black listing is an old Soviet trick.
winn dixie's Avatar
Racist reckoning.

Good one Dilbert! Thats exactly whats happening
I think they should tell the DPST's to fuck off.
dilbert firestorm's Avatar
there have been a few more firings.

even a New Orleans Mardi Gras krewe was not immune. this one is different, its where the members fired the captain and they did this by quitting.

krewe captain Julie Lea of the Mystic Krewe of Nix, an all female krewe (3,000+ members), posted "All Lives Matter" on Facebook or Twitter (I forget which). there was push back by the members who said that was racist. She apologized. but that wasn't enough. the float Lieutenants demanded that she resign. She refused. In the process, about 60 float Lieutenants resigned. This was followed later by more members quitting the organization. Dance troupes and bands also disassociated with Nix.

not sure how many quit, but it looks like she lost half of the membership.

https://www.nola.com/news/article_53...673af6c88.html
dilbert firestorm's Avatar
https://quillette.com/2020/07/09/it-...let-it-happen/


It Wasn’t My Cancelation That Bothered Me. It Was the Cowardice of Those Who Let It Happen

written by Margaret Wente
Published on July 9, 2020



It doesn’t take much to get cancelled these days. Last month, my turn came around. The experience was unpleasant, but also completely ludicrous. And I learned a lot. I learned how easily an institution will cave to a mob. I learned how quickly the authorities will run for cover, notwithstanding the lip service they may pay to principles of free speech.

After all, they’re terrified. They’re afraid that if they don’t beg forgiveness and promise to do better, they’ll be next at the guillotine.

I was cancelled by one of Canada’s quainter institutions, a University of Toronto graduate residential school called Massey College. Few people outside Canadian academia have heard of it. But the cultural revolution has entered its mass-spectacle Reign of Terror phase, and so my story made news across Canada. I was depicted as a racist, anti-feminist heretic whose mere presence inside Massey’s halls would have presented a threat to students.

But Massey College hasn’t fared too well, either: In this climate, every fusty institution is just one trivial scandal away from public-relations crisis and knives-out infighting, as all concerned flail about in a bid to prove their moral purity. I’ll survive. I’m not sure Massey will.
* * *
Massey College was created in the early 1960s by Torontonians eager to evoke the genteel old Oxbridge days. And it remains a charming place, though a bit precious. It is made up of senior fellows (distinguished professors from the university, as well as luminaries from the city’s intellectual elite) and junior fellows (graduate students), who don their gowns to dine together, and perhaps mingle over a glass of port. The senior fellows are overwhelmingly white; the junior fellows increasingly multicultural. Until recently, the head of the college held the anachronistic title of “Master”, after the British style. Yet despite these antiquated trappings, Massey College prides itself on being a vibrant forum for high-minded debate and liberal ideals.

The college has an appendage called the Quadrangle Society, which is basically a jumped-up book club. Its members, of whom there are hundreds, are drawn from the non-academic world. Although membership is by invitation only, it is not terribly exclusive, and nobody is quite sure of its purpose. It is a WASPish take on what once might have been called a “salon”—back in the days when words like that could be used unironically without provoking eye rolls.

Last winter, I was asked to join. I said yes because I have several friends who belong to the Quadrangle Society, and I thought this would be a fun excuse for us to have lunch together in Massey’s great hall. Two Quadranglers wrote too-kind nomination letters for me. I was assured that the approval process was a mere formality. And sure enough, in due course I received a call from the recently appointed head (whose title now has been changed to “Principal”). She was delighted to inform me that I’d been accepted. And there my troubles began.

I am a journalist, now mostly retired, who for several decades served as a senior editor, and then an opinion columnist, for the Globe and Mail, the closest thing Canada has to a New York Times. Some of my opinions were controversial—or at least what passes for controversial in this country. My specialty was deflating Canada’s numerous liberal pieties. I did it rather well. Among Canada’s liberal elites, who take their pieties very seriously, I was an abomination.

I attracted controversy for another reason, too. In 2012, I was accused of plagiarism. While my newspaper found me guilty of nothing more than carelessness, there is no question that I screwed up by failing to attribute material to other sources. My critics gleefully seized on the incident, and I’ve been trolled on social media ever since. The issue also became a convenient rallying point for the mob that assembled once my appointment to the Quadrangle Society was announced (along with about two dozen other appointees).

Massey College was besieged by enraged students and faculty. Racism featured heavily among the sins attributed to me, even though I’d scarcely written about race at all during my career. (This was in June, at the peak of the Black Lives Matter protests. And in that moment, some race-related accusation figured in most mobbings.)

Sexism, too. Because I had written in the Globe and Mail that the prevalence of rape on university campuses had been highly exaggerated, I was accused of “creating an unsafe environment for disclosures of misconduct.” I was also denounced for questioning the science behind “implicit bias” training (which has, in fact, been thoroughly discredited). I was even accused of “self-plagiarism,” the journalistic equivalent of #MeToo-ing oneself.

“I thought Massey had just resolved to educate its members about racism and microaggression and do better to create a safe and welcoming environment for marginalised people,” one complainant wrote. “And then we invited Margaret Wente to join us? Seriously? How are my friends and colleagues supposed to feel safe sitting across from her at dinner?”

Dozens of scholars threatened to resign from the college if my appointment were allowed to stand. A few did so pre-emptively, in fact. They included Alissa Trotz, director of the University of Toronto’s Women & Gender Studies Institute. “Margaret Wente is someone who has demonstrated consistent and outright hostility to questions of equity, women and gender studies and anti-racism,” she wrote in her letter of resignation. Trotz claimed that she hadn’t been aware of my nomination—an odd claim given that she’d been a member of Massey’s governing council and sat on the governance and nominating committee.

The principal of the college (a francophone from Ottawa) was blindsided. She seemed to be the only person among Toronto’s intellectual elite who wasn’t aware of my chequered reputation. As for the board of governors, I don’t know how my name sneaked by them. (Actually, I do know. They thought the Quadrangle Society was an innocuous outfit that could continue holding its book clubs and cocktail parties in well-heeled obscurity.)

It didn’t help that Massey was already under a racist cloud, due to a single bad joke. Three years ago, a retired professor named Michael Marrus, then a senior fellow, attempted to make a clumsy poke at the old designation of “master” within Massey College. “You know this is your master, eh?” he said to one of the Black junior fellows, referring to the then-head of the college. “Do you feel the lash?”

Needless to say, this joke did not go over well. Prof. Marrus was forced out, and offered his profuse apologies; as did Massey College, begging for everyone’s forgiveness for longer than was necessary or dignified, and thereby setting the stage for the even sillier scandal involving me. Last year, a new principal was found who, it was devoutly hoped, would help the college turn the page: Nathalie Des Rosiers, a lawyer, academic, and former Liberal politician who once served, if you can believe it, as general counsel for the Canadian Civil Liberties Association.

It was Ms. Des Rosiers who called me to deliver the unpleasant news about the firestorm. She sounded stunned, as if she’d been whacked by a two-by-four. She wasn’t specific about the allegations, but apologetically told me she would have to strike a committee to look into them. She also told me she hoped this unpleasantness could be resolved by respectful dialogue. I thought this sentiment was utterly naïve. Mobs aren’t interested in dialogue. The whole purpose of a mob is to punish heretics and prove to everyone where the power lies. She gently asked if I might want to resign. I said I didn’t know.

Shortly after our little chat, Massey College issued a statement announcing that in light of the objections, my appointment was going to be re-examined in order to determine whether I was really fit to receive the honor that had been bestowed on me. “New information” had come to light since I’d been approved—which everyone knew was complete nonsense, since everything I’d ever written exists on the Globe and Mail web site and various searchable media databases. For good measure, Massey College cited the college’s code of conduct, which “expresses specifically a commitment to equity and diversity,” and added that “racist statements cannot and will not be tolerated.” Ms. Des Rosiers hadn’t bothered to inform me that this denunciation was in the works. From what I could tell, everyone at Massey was in full panic mode, completely focused on protecting their own positions.

Two days later, the principal called me with an update. Massey’s governing board had called an urgent emergency session to deal with the Wente crisis. It was clear where this was heading. So I quit.



Massey’s statement announcing my resignation followed a now familiar formula, with the authors reciting lurid confessions of vast thought crimes that extended well beyond inviting a former newspaper columnist to occasional literary cocktail parties. The governing board promised to launch a “fundamental rethink… in order to eliminate any impediments to an environment that is completely free from anti-Black racism, anti-Indigenous racism, anti-gender identity views and discrimination of any kind.” It pledged that this effort “will become the primary focus of the Governing Board in the months to come.” In the few weeks between my joining the Quadrangle Society and my leaving it, the group had apparently gone from a cheese-plate book club to a full-time woke struggle session.

Without a hint of irony, the Massey College statement also described the school as “a beacon for the expression of the widest range of academic viewpoints.” But as my case shows, these two goals are completely contradictory. You can raise a beacon for free expression. Or you can run a puritanical campaign to enforce moral purity and root out heretics. You can’t have both. And to an astonishing extent, the people who run places with names like the Quadrangle Society have chosen moral purity.
* * *
I’m not ashamed to find myself in the company of the cancelled. Indeed, I’m proud to share this honour with some of the finest minds in the world. One example is Steve Hsu, a brilliant scientist who, until late June, was vice-president of research and innovation at Michigan State University (whose status he’s helped to vastly improve). Hsu was forced out by the university’s president, who caved in to pressure from the graduate students’ union (though Hsu will keep the academic part of his job because he has tenure). Among his sins: He mentioned published research, from his own university, that found no racial bias in police shootings. He also once wrote approvingly of peer-reviewed, government-funded research on variations in brain architecture that is now casually labelled as “scientific racism.”

In the latter case, Hsu was writing about a 2015 article in the journal Current Biology, and his comments were not immediately seen as particularly controversial. This was only five years ago. Yet the times have utterly changed during that period. The wrong kind of science is now seen as hate speech. The same is true of any failure to place Black Lives Matter activists in the firmament of earthly angels. Even liking the wrong tweets can cost you your career. Mike McCulloch, a math lecturer at the University of Plymouth, was recently investigated by his employer for liking a tweet that read “All lives matter.” Here in Canada, Michael Korenberg, chair of the board of governors for the University of British Columbia, was forced to step down because he liked some tweets praising Donald Trump. Nobody is safe—not even the phenomenally popular author J.K. Rowling, who has been hounded and harassed for saying that, when it comes to trans women, biology is still a thing.

My own field, journalism, has become notoriously full of little inquisitors. In the most disturbing example, James Bennet, opinion editor of the most important paper in the world, the New York Times, lost his job in June for publishing an opinion piece that many of the younger staffers didn’t like. It was written by a Republican senator, Tom Cotton, who argued that Donald Trump would be justified in deploying military troops to cities if local police could not maintain order in the streets. Staffers claimed the piece was so toxic that it put some of their colleagues’ lives in danger. Like many others, Mr. Bennet departed with a grovelling apology.

If you think the radical mob is now editing your daily paper, you might well be right. Last month, Stan Wischnowski, top editor at the Philadelphia Inquirer, was forced to resign over a headline that read, “Buildings Matter, Too.” All of this is dolefully reminiscent of China’s Cultural Revolution, during which students denounced their elders and made them parade through the streets in dunce hats before they were packed off to the pig farms for re-education.

And there is no statute of limitations. Last week, Boeing’s communications chief, Niel Golightly, abruptly resigned after an anonymous employee filed an ethics complaint over an article he wrote in 1987, 33 years ago. In it, the former military pilot had expressed the opinion that women shouldn’t serve in combat (a mainstream position at the time). “My argument was embarrassingly wrong and offensive,” he said in another cringe worthy mea culpa. “The article is not reflective of who I am.”

So be warned. Everything you ever said or wrote is fair game. As the well-known social psychologist Jonathan Haidt tweeted the other day, “If scholars scan each other’s collective work—every word written or recorded—searching for the least charitable reading of every snippet, we can all destroy each other.”
* * *
Compared to other cancel-culture targets, I’m one of the lucky ones. I no longer have a job on the line. And so I get to spend the summer reading books and visiting with friends instead of mucking out the pig farm.

As a columnist, I had strong editors to back me up. And I wrote at a time when you could speak your mind. In the last few years, by contrast, the window for even mildly controversial opinions has shrunk dramatically. It has shrunk the most at places that have traditionally prided themselves as champions of free expression. As ideological correctness becomes the modern currency of spiritual virtue, rational dissent has been cast as heresy.

I wish the folks at Massey College well. But they’ll have a hard time turning their 1960s take on Oxford into a woke utopia that will satisfy their critics. And the sight of their panic is blood in the water for the same folks who came after me. There is no way they can cleanse themselves of the stain of white privilege. Ultimately, the only way they’ll be able to atone for their sins is to cancel themselves.

Margaret Wente is a former editor and columnist for the Globe and Mail newspaper. Now happily retired, she lives in Toronto.
  • oeb11
  • 07-23-2020, 02:24 PM
DF - Thank - a scathing indictment of the Orwellian thought control police culture of the DPST radicals.

If they are elected - free speech is gone in America. It is already just a remnant as a buzz word for 'cancel culture DPST doublespeak"!

However - if the DPST radicals (Bernie-Biden -Beto) think they will cancel the Second Amendment in middle America - they will incite civil war!
rexdutchman's Avatar
the LSM is having a great time persecuting anyone with a non-socialist opinion. " The thought police " are here
free speech is gone in America. It is already just a remnant as a buzz word for 'cancel culture DPST doublespeak"!
1984 is here
What a bunch of pussies in this world!

Fuck all white liberals you have created this fucked up society!
pfunkdenver's Avatar
What a bunch of pussies in this world!

Fuck all white liberals you have created this fucked up society! Originally Posted by friendly fred
I find this hilarious!

Triggered white snowflake calls liberals pussies! Liberals fucked up his world! I see him whining and crying like a child. Cry on snowflake!

Good Lord! Does anyone in this forum have a pair of balls?
I find this hilarious!

Triggered white snowflake calls liberals pussies! Liberals fucked up his world! I see him whining and crying like a child. Cry on snowflake!

Good Lord! Does anyone in this forum have a pair of balls? Originally Posted by pfunkdenver
I'm not on the side of "safe spaces" and close the schools because someone might get sick and die a few months earlier than their time to go.

I'm not on the side of the little pussies like the soy boys from Portland who don't want to hear anything that offends them.

I would beat their faces into the ground and spit on them.
rexdutchman's Avatar
It is already just a remnant as a buzz word for 'cancel culture DPST doublespeak"!
1984 is here
You can only said what been approved by the socialist liberals