Reviews on 'page 1 or page 4', does it matter when picking an escort??

Do any guys actually give a shit what page the current review of a lady is on, or do the ladies even care? Personally, I think it is a huge misconception that if a lady is on the top of page 1 or even 2 for a week that she is getting better appointment odds. When I choose a lady I look at her ad of course ( which runs it weekly course) but I look at 2-3-4 sometimes even 5 pages of ads/reviews when I'm on the hunt.

Than I look at reviews. The first five have just as much a shot of further interest as the last 5 on page 4 or 6. Most guys about to shell out $100-$500 are going to do research on ECCIE and elsewhere where reviews are. If a girl gets bumped from page 3 to page one either from a picture or a reply it doesn't mean anything to me.

So what is all this fuss about not just G-Man posting a picture but anyone who bumps a thread. Most guys look beyond the first page when choosing, so what is the big deal about the first page? Does it really make the girl more money? Are guys really that lazy that they will pick a page one girl and totally skip researching latter pages?

Well, I don't think it matters where the review is, what page it is on, if it was bumped by a WK saying ' way to go' or if GM posted a pic. NONE of those influence my decision. I can find her pics on my own and before I pay I'll research all her reviews, the one on page one, the one on page four and the ones in her profile which could be well over a month(s) ago..

Too much page one can also ' backfire'; if I want to see a lady and she has 7 reviews on pages 1-2, I might assume ( perhaps wrongly) that she is a factory taking back to back appointments and is ' too busy' so will focus my efforts elsewhere.

I look at 2-3-4 sometimes even 5 pages of ads/reviews when I'm on the hunt.
Originally Posted by KosherCowboy

Yep same here, but i usually do it to find out if the provider is consistence.. I avoid a known YMMV provider.. Consistence, clean, and dirty service is what I want. So, the answer to your question is nada for me I dont care if her review is on page 1 or 1000 I just want consistence.. So I hunt..

I don't make snap decisions, I do a fair bit of research, so which reviews are on page 1 on a given day doesn't matter to me. Its the content and consistency of the reviews (and reviewers) that I pay attention to. I also appreciate informative commentary in posts from other hobbyists in the review threads; bumping a review three weeks later to say "ooh, I've got to see her" doesn't qualify.

I search for certain physical qualities and then start reading.... I make a list of a few and then start communicating.... so it probably doesn't matter to me.

Whether it Page 1 or Page 5 or even 6 or 7..doesnt make a difference to me..Its called RESEARCH .....And its just part of it..

I just started getting reviews on Eccie in the last 6 months or so, and never noticed a rise in business because of them. I think a simple google search or clicking the links in one's sig line, should give just as much insight. Having tons of reviews always on the front page might be more of an indicator of volume IMO, but not much else.

I guess I never got all caught up in reviews being I feel they mean nothing other than one guy's opinion. They don't mean you are pretty, great in bed, or superior for sure but to some ladies what others say about them defines who they are.

I'm one that skims them all dailey so I keep up. I make a metal note. But a current review on one I made a mental note on usually is the reason I then book. I tend to stay away from the flavor of the month though. But I do see them months later.

It makes no difference to me where the reviews fall because I typically look at the ads first. If the description of the provider grabs my interest I click on the link to her reviews to check what others have to say. At that point I make my decision. I very seldom check out the review forum anymore but in the rare instance that I find a provider by doing so I search her reviews. Where they fall does not matter to me.

I scroll through the ads until I find something that interests me; physical attributes, activities BCD, TCB attitude, price points, etc. Then I'll make a move.

Frankly, there are far too few ladies posting ads here for my liking. I use the reviews more than the ads, since there's a chance that I'll be reading about someone new.

i really look for no's on seeing the provider again. how many has she had, what was the reasons for the no. if the review makes sense and information is given about the reason and are just and real. then i will contact the provider and ask about the review. Then go back and read the reviews of her yes's. then weight the good against the bad. just cause one or even two no's have shown up on her doesn't mean i will not choose her. as far as where is it in the list of reviews that makes no difference. cause sometime is days or even up to a week when the client does the review.

I think OP (or should I say, old timer ? :-) should also have included a "depends" ?

I'll explain my reasoning:

If it's a come and go BP type girl, then yes - it does matter. Exclusive BP girls are "generally" flaky, and services and tactics change - far too often for me to be able to keep up with.

If it's a ECCIE gal, there are a FEW, who have ... let's say ... a less than trustworthy reputation. If one scrols back enough, one sees several reviews with questionable judgements. When I see this, I search the provider's post during then next few days and weeks and look for what she posted, and the DEMEANOR of how she presented herself.

Based on what I discover and how SHE REPRESENTED HERSELF under fire, I draw my own conclusions. I try to draw my own conclusions based on the black and white that's out there, rather than relying on the judgements of "he said", "she said", and what "everyone else" said.

Perhaps a fallacy on my part, but I think that 2 years of mostly solid rep, generally speaking, outweighs the input from 2 unsatisfied customers in one week.

So for me, the answer is "it depends".

It doesn't matter to me if they have a review on the first page. I am gonna research the shit out of her first and read most of the list of her reviews. I also want to make sure that she had been reviewed by someone I know and trust on here as well.

I think OP (or should I say, old timer ? :-) should also have included a "depends" ?


So for me, the answer is "it depends". Originally Posted by rrrabbit

If she wears Depends it's a definite NO FUCKING WAY.

If she wears Depends it's a definite NO FUCKING WAY. Originally Posted by Budman

I can clearly see the validity of your input.

TY sir.

Someone once asked me what a 70-yr. old tasted like .. I said "Depends!"