There's a lot of fantastic food that doesn't quality as 5 star. Curious what people have loved.
My selections:
Baltimore: Ze Mean Bean (best Polish food EVER), Ambassador
New York: Dervish for the lamb, Aroma for the pasta, The Orchard (not sure if it's still open), Little Giant, Cafe Katja
Washington: Taberna Del Alabardero
New Orleans: The Orange Couch (for Thai Milkshake), Dante's Kitchen, Bennachin, Yo MaMa's, Port Of Call, Coop's Place, Sucre, Checkpoint Charlies
Toronto: Ethiopian House, Foxley Bistro, Shanghai Cowgirl, Rush Hour