first off, i hear where you are coming from, Dear_John. it's not a silly argument by any means.
but soft power is a thing, and real politik says we should use it. we always have used it, and it has always worked to our benefit. and if we don't use it, our enemies like China will.
one day we're pulling bodies from the rubble, and the next maybe we're offering to set up some military bases in Burma to counter China, Russia, North Korea, and Iran.
we didn't have to rebuild Japan after WWII. we could have said, "Look, you started this shit at Pearl Harbor, so we owe you exactly jack shit, all total. Enjoy the radiation."
did we do that? no. we pulled up our sleeves and went to work to help rebuild the cities that Truman evaporated. and who received the benefit? we did, and Japan did. in any WWIII scenario against the 4 enemy states i mentioned above, Japan is one of our most reliable allies, and potentially a military juggernaut that will keep China busy af in any Taiwan invasion scenario, giving our 11 carriers plenty of room to operate. (btw, this is no damn time to retire carriers.)
same with Greenland. instead of threatening this poor country with a military invasion, we could use soft power to improve their economy and standard of living. then we can say with a straight face, "hey Greenland, we hooked you up. is it cool if we add to your defensive positioning against thugs like China and Russia? i mean who's to say Russia won't invade you next like they did Ukraine?"
China has used soft power in Africa and South America totally to our detriment. we are sitting behind the 8 ball, while China has turned half of those countries into resource-producing slave states. we're asleep at the switch while China is busy as bees.
soft power costs a lot less than hard power and it's beneficial to us in terms of real politik. Trump has it all wrong.
but for sure, all props to Flying Physicians and other orgs working on straight charity. but charity doesn't pay the light bills or put food on the table for our ngos, who do great work around the world, just like the CDC. honestly, it's incredible that the CDC is even a part of government, they are so damn good. and Musk and Trump just kneecapped the CDC. terrible decision that will have mind-boggling ramifications for public health.
please enlighten me on why we should baby sit the world? I don't pay taxes to send money all around the world, we have enough issues here to tend to. Now if people want to go to foreign countries on their own dime, so be it. My BIL was a doctor and he and his son went to Indonesia or somewhere when they had a horrible tidal wave and earthquakes, and he gave his time and effort to help out those needing help, and I deeply admired him for this. However like I said, I want our tax dollars spent here.
Originally Posted by DEAR_JOHN