The macro concern I have that no one (or few) is talking about is the sharp contraction in demand once everyone restructures their balance sheets...that is the guy making $50K is now actually living on $50; not $75 or $100K like in the old days. This contraction will cut across all sectors, not just housing.
Originally Posted by atlcomedy
...I saw (the other day) that the savings rate had increased to 6% from 3% here recently. But the long term savings rate had historically averaged around 9%. Now I'm not sure I know what that percentage really means...but I do know that it means that there will be less money flowing around the system to create jobs. Balance Sheets will start to look better...but revenue will (in total) be less.
Originally Posted by Rudyard K
Those are both good points and in my opinion cut to the heart of the imbalances our economy faces today.
The savings rate was indeed reported to be around 6% recently. That's just a snapshot in time (it's always a moving target and a little difficult to measure). But I believe most observers think that after they report the next string of several-month moving averages you will see that the household savings rate is in the mid-single digit range. That's up from several years of near-zero reports.
By contrast, for several decades following World War II the savings rate tended to be around 10%. Consumption was a lower percentage of GDP, but we were a manufacturing and exporting colossus, and we were the world's largest creditor nation.. But just look at us now. It's sad and pathetic.
We are the largest
debtor nation in the history of the world and we have a balance-of-payments deficit approaching $500 billion annually. Much of it goes for goods imported from China and for imported oil which we promptly burn up. In the meantime, we don't export nearly enough.
The Chinese print renminbi like crazy and the PBOC buys massive quantities of dollars so they can keep their side of the dollar/yuan pair undervalued by 30-40%, thus gaining a huge export advantage. China is the largest and most aggressive mercantilist power in the history of the world.
We need less debt-fueled consumption and more savings, investment, production, and exports. I don't believe for a minute that we'll ever have a sound recovery until we begin moving in that direction and rebalancing our economy in a sound manner.
The getting there is what's going to be tough.
It's so much easier for politicians to say, "Free ice cream for everybody! The fat kid down the street will eat your broccoli for you."