Yes recommendations

There are many reasons why a gent might decide that he would not return to see a lady, even though she lived up to her end of the bargain.

Were the pics her? Yes
Were her TCB skills good? Yes
Was her attitude positive? Yes
Was her menu what you expected? Yes
Did you receive the full time allotted? Yes

She earned a yes recommendation. Period.

"No" means stay away. If she did nothing to warrant a cautionary tale, then she earned a yes.

Maybe she had tattoos that turned you off, maybe her BBBJ was a turn off to you - you like it slow and sensual and her style is fast and intense, or vice versa. Maybe she had evidence of "baby damage" as some guys like to call it, and that turns you off. These are all valid reasons why one guy would decide not to see an otherwise excellent provider.

If she lives up to her end of the deal with her attitude and performance, then give her the yes she deserves, and explain in the ROS why you personally would not return. That lives up to your obligation of giving a fair and objective review, while also giving her the kudos she deserves for doing her job well.

The peanut gallery is about to say "But guys without PA can't see the ROS". Well, tough. All it takes is one review, or paying for PA access to see the additional information available in the ROS.

The peanut gallery is about to say "But guys without PA can't see the ROS". Well, tough. All it takes is one review, or paying for PA access to see the additional information available in the ROS. Originally Posted by SinsOfTheFlesh

Well fine then.....

I ain't no peanut though.....

Salted or in the shell!! I agree with Stacy sof. Some people like ham and some like turkey.

I'm hesitant to throw shade on guys that review regulary since i quit reviewing long ago, but it's obvious that an awful lot of guys choose to "manufacture" reviews for PA and to use as a resume for seeing providers. You do that and put out enough NOs and you're hurting yourself.
Add to that the fact that... how do i put this... some guys are just bitches who are afraid of offending (not really trying to be misogynistic here, but it is what it is) a hooker that they've just paid to suck their dick.
is right, but how many times here have you seen somebody on the scout team hang a NO on a new girl and get kudos for TOFT, but you give an honest NO about somebody with a fan club and:

(clip filmed at the Applebee's next to the World's Record Longest Consecutive Incall.)

Maybe there needs to be another option other than a straight YES or NO. To me a No is warranted for a few reasons such as hygiene, poor performance, poor attitude not delivering as advertised.

If the provider ends up as a blonde bimbo with no smarts and I like a girl with some intelligence, I won't see her again. But she lived up to all as advertised, does that warrant a NO? Originally Posted by BigMikeinKC

Personally, I think they oughta have a rating system. Maybe it's a number of stars or something that allows for subtleties. But for now, we've just got yes or no. So if it's not all yes, then it's no.

:

(clip filmed at the Applebee's next to the World's Record Longest Consecutive Incall.) Originally Posted by zeejoe

I agree with that kaos. Rating system seems it would make it simpler & more accurate.

I sometimes edit my reviews to change the simple "Yes" or "No" to something more descriptive.

- I wouldn't repeat with her, but I would recommend her to someone interested in a young, thin provider
- Yes, as long as you don't mind the lack of GFE. If you just want to get off, she's the girl. And those boobs are worth it.
- I got what I paid for. Won't repeat.
- Yes, as long as you know what the place is and isn't. It isn't Baby Dolls. At midnight on a Saturday, it isn't much at all.
- Yes, but not if looking for GFE
- Yes, I assume that she was having an off day, and would go back to see her or Roxie.
- Hell to the Yes

Personally, I think they oughta have a rating system. Maybe it's a number of stars or something that allows for subtleties. But for now, we've just got yes or no. So if it's not all yes, then it's no. Originally Posted by CaptainKaos

better yet instead of the question:
recommendation:

have PA access based on
1 would you see her again?
1a explain answer to 1..

because a yes/no is not good enough, a guy wants to know why see her, why does the john who saw her want to see her/not see her again
that would give more concrete info than a yes/no or 7/10
because somethings for some guys(greek) are 11/10, but other guys don't like that shit* *(pun intended)
so a rating or a vague YES isnt enough info
but the explaination for the recommendation could be PA only. so guys would want PA to get more than yes/no

(clip filmed at the Applebee's next to the World's Record Longest Consecutive Incall.) Originally Posted by zeejoe

This may be my only contribution to this thread, but I totally agree with KCQ's suggestion that the reviewer edit the simple "Yes/No" choice to a clearer, more descriptive recommendation. With this, everyone gets to see the caveats, and not just those with PA access that might be able to "read between the lines" of the ROS contents.

I sometimes edit my reviews to change the simple "Yes" or "No" to something more descriptive.

- I wouldn't repeat with her, but I would recommend her to someone interested in a young, thin provider
- Yes, as long as you don't mind the lack of GFE. If you just want to get off, she's the girl. And those boobs are worth it.
- I got what I paid for. Won't repeat.
- Yes, as long as you know what the place is and isn't. It isn't Baby Dolls. At midnight on a Saturday, it isn't much at all.
- Yes, but not if looking for GFE
- Yes, I assume that she was having an off day, and would go back to see her or Roxie.
- Hell to the Yes Originally Posted by KCQuestor

Does it get any clearer than YES or NO ?
Think about how some of the guys on here profile out... You really want a deeper exploration of MexiCopter69's decision-making process?
Go back and read the OP again, y'all.

I agree that a rating system would be a lot better. Even if it's just YES, NO, and Meh...

Give me some grey area to play with.

I think we should have a star system....right Kaylen?

Kaylen?

The last item on the review is not "Would you see her again?" Instead, it is "Would you recommend her to other guys?" Considering how many different things guys like, I might very well recommend a girl who I would never see again myself.