Gotta give it to the OP, whether you hate him or you hate him (and it seems like he's actually bringing everyone together), he's keeping things interesting.
I happen to agree. Whether ladies have other accounts, friendly white knights, or mod assistance, they can typically get the gyst of reviews if they want. I think allowing them to see it poses no real issues and perhaps allows them to get insight on what they are good at or could be better at. A good provider would be able to use that to provide better service.