My 15 years of experience is YMMV on first visits. A ton of variables including, but not limited to chemistry and attraction, time of day, how far she is into her stint, her level of experience, and sometimes most importantly, the dickhead who proceeded you.
That being said, I found Shiny very attractive but our session was one of my less satisfactory. In fact she made it a point to tell me to stay with Bunny and not see her again. I’d point OP towards Cindy, Flower, Perfect, or Shasha in no particular order. Well within anyone’s aesthetic range with consistent performance above the norm.