Guitar,I completely understand and sympathize with the reaction the original poster got, and I'm certainly not trying to pick on you.
You got her riled up because whether you meant it or not, your statement that you were "disappointed" in yourself is rude and demeaning. It dehumanizes the women you saw, as it's basically saying that because they weren't your preferred body type that they're worthless trash. The fact that you chose them yourself makes it even worse.
We all have preferences. If you go away from yours, don't trash the girls because of it. Originally Posted by TheBizz
But . . . buyer's remorse and publicly expressing one's disappointment in a tryst are, arguably, part of the core function of a board like this. Writing a review with a "no" recommendation, and explaining that you thought she wasn't as attractive as you'd hoped, may be unpleasant and even rude or gratuitously cruel in some instances. (Particularly if you knew before scheduling that you would find her unattractive, but it's not clear that was the case with the original poster.) But I wouldn't automatically equate it to thinking/saying that the lady was "worthless trash." And to the extent that it's dehumanizing, it's an almost inevitable result of P4P as financial transaction and a P4P board as Consumer Reports.
If it's dehumanizing, or saying that a lady is "worthless trash," all clients are guilty to some extent, if only by omission. We all decline to see some ladies because to us they're not attractive; most of us at one time or another have seen a lady who turned out to be less attractive (to us) than we realized from descriptions or available pictures. That we may not want to have sex with them doesn't necessarily mean we consider them trash.
In other words, it seems that the original poster's sin (if any) was not so much that he considered certain ladies he'd seen to be unattractive, as that it was rude/gratuitously cruel to mention it publicly. And even then, only if it's not an important element of an otherwise appropriate discussion.
*shrug* My opinion. YOMV