Herein lies the fallacy of the left's view of life because most believe that it doesn't matter how they behave because they had no choice as they were "destined" to be one thing or another. Well, how does anyone know what their destiny is? Maybe God spoke to them and told them? More than likely they just decided (free will) that their situation is what is and will act according to what they believe they are limited to.
Originally Posted by nsafun05
I knew I was talking over your head so I tried to preemptively dumb it down but even that didn't work. I put free will (yay!!!!) and fate (boooo!!!) to make it easy for you but you even got that backwards, claiming that "the left" resigns themselves to their fates and that you ("the right") assert your free will.
God or free will; that is your choice. You can't have both. In fact, you can only truly choose free will. You cannot choose God because if there is a God then he's already determined your so-called choice.
Again, the examples about God being like your parents, the government, etc are missing the point entirely. God is supposed to be the all-knowing, all-seeing creator of the Universe. More to the point, why would you spend your life trying to please Him when a being like that is impossible to please? (If God was playing Blackjack and got a 21 he couldn't even crack a smile because he cannot be surprised. He already knows how the cards will turn because he
created the cards and sees the future.) It's also impossible for a being like that to laugh. Laughter requires surprise. Trying to compare an imaginary being like that to your parents, the government, other real things, etc is pointless. You can only compare omniscient, omnipresent Universe creators to other omniscient, omnipresent Universe creators.
One more time just to pound it in...if you believe in God then you
must believe that your fate is pre-determined. Because if you
did have a little bit of free will...then that would be something out of God's control...and he wouldn't be all-powerful or all-knowing...and thus...NOT God.