I called "Shelby" from a backpage ad about 3 years ago. Definitely NOT the girl in the pic. She was nice enough, but the age difference, body type difference (much heavier than in the fake pic) were too much for me to really get turned on.
Thing is, she seemed nice enough, and I'll bet there are enough guys out there who would book her based on seeing her real pics.
I've seen a couple of fairly large grandmotherly types repeatedly posting on BP....so they seem to be getting calls....there is someone for everyone, eh?