Do I get a cookie?
You must try Oban. It is an excellent drop. I find it light and smoky with a good balance. I personally don't add water but then I don't normally take a cask strength.
Originally Posted by SAangel27
I grant wishes.
I agree that I need to try Oban, simply cause what's in my mind is something 1/2 way between Talisker and either Glenfiddich or Glenlivert. With Talisker being very smoky whereas the other 2 are both more delicate. It's rare that I do much with whisky than either neat, or over no more than one or two cubes, so I can enjoy the flavor. Thus, you've presented a temptation that will have to be satisfied.