Woah now that's going too far. The movies are almost like an impressionistic overview of the story going through the best looking scenes with just the bare bones of storyline. I feel like the main reason I enjoyed them was bc I *had* read the books and was now getting some illustrations to put along side the text. Plus the core themes are totally lost - the various hobbits were able to do what they did not bc they were powerful but *because* they were meek and humble.
Originally Posted by Balderfiddle
See, I'm the opposite. The books had way too much extraneous stuff (all the walking around, singing, Tom Bombadill,
good god the endless singing!) for my taste. I enjoyed the movies more because it trimmed things down to something more palatable as opposed to something that would make you constipated when you read it.
To be fair, I always hated hobbits. Don't trust the sneaky hairy-footed bastards.