I lost a lot of weight a couple of years ago, and am today in much better shape than for the prior 15 years.
I can honestly say that I don't think that I am treated any differently now than I was when I was pushing 300 lbs. Many of the same ladies are very complimentary, which sure feels great. But they are mostly the same, fun, genuine ladies I met with when one pop was a lucky end to the hour.
I see the same type of folks now that I did then, and screen to have an idea that the are the type I would enjoy. I have not changed who I like to see, and have not yearned to see the hot PYT's that enter and leave our hobby frequently. My compliments to the ladies that enjoy a genuine session with someone that has no intent other to have some fun, and try to help you do the same. You guys rock!
YMMV indeed, but I suspect it has less to do with looking like Brad Pitt, and more with being nice, respectful, and to someone's point freshly showered!