I lost a lot of weight a couple of years ago, and am today in much better shape than for the prior 15 years.
I can honestly say that I don't think that I am treated any differently now than I was when I was pushing 300 lbs. Many of the same ladies are very complimentary, which sure feels great. But they are mostly the same, fun, genuine ladies I met with when one pop was a lucky end to the hour.
I see the same type of folks now that I did then, and screen to have an idea that the are the type I would enjoy. I have not changed who I like to see, and have not yearned to see the hot PYT's that enter and leave our hobby frequently. My compliments to the ladies that enjoy a genuine session with someone that has no intent other to have some fun, and try to help you do the same. You guys rock!
YMMV indeed, but I suspect it has less to do with looking like Brad Pitt, and more with being nice, respectful, and to someone's point freshly showered!
)....but let's face it. Physical or not, if you're compatible you're bound to have a better time than if there is some awkward silences and nothing in common.