I love this post, Poet Laureate. It saddens me you feel like there will be repercussions for making it. I don't doubt you (although I don't really understand what you mean by that). I just wish it wasn't true.
One of the things I find interesting is this overall cultural identity with how
special everyone is who chooses to participate in the hobby. It's like being at the Alamo, where Colonel Travis draws a line in the sand, and only those who are willing to cross the line end up being defenders to their death.
I'm not saying it's not true. There is a specialness involved in choosing to participate in an illegal activity which involves physical intimacy, and extreme vulnerability on emotional, financial, professional, familial, and societal levels.
But it's not like this dynamic doesn't exist all over the place. Get involved in a group of skydivers, or marathon runners, or hedge traders, or drug users, or wildcatters, or special forces, or crafters, or D&D eventers, or ANYTHING which involves making a conscious decision to step away from the rest of your peer group, to become an outlier. They ALL feel like they're a part of a
special subculture. Hell, one of the magical things about the internet is that no matter how out there the subculture you've identified yourself with, it's virtually certain there are other people who share it with you.
And the more we invest in this activity, the more bonded we are with other people who make the same decision, and the less we're able to share of ourselves with anyone outside of that activity.
That's how it works. For very personal reasons, those of us in this forum have made the choice to cross that line, whether as a provider or as a client, and that bell can never be unrung. Like the joke goes, once you suck one cock, you're always known as a cocksucker. Same goes with being a provider or a hobbyist, even if it's only internal, and no one else in the "civilian world" knows about it.
Some of the complications of this stuff are very unique. But some of them are challenges plenty of other industries/hobbies/occupations face.
The first occupation I always think about with a similar challenge to the hobby, is psychological therapy.
The difference is that counselors at all levels go through a great deal of training, whereas there's no such thing as a Provider University (although I would found one if it was feasible!).
Counseling training talks about the difference between "empathy" and "sympathy", and the importance of distinguishing between the two. Empathy is when you listen with your heart, but you don't emotionally identify with the person. Sympathy is when you start identifying with the person's struggles. A line is crossed, which can lead to an unproductive and emotionally dangerous treatment.
One of the techniques I've read about is 'anchoring', where you anchor one figurative foot in reality. You know who you are, what's important to you, where your values come from, what you go home to, etc.. Then you take your other figurative foot, and take a step into the other person's world.
Frankly, it sounds like it would be pretty fucking complicated in the real world, but there you are.
Other professions like police enforcement, military action, CPS workers, health industry workers (specifically in intensive care, nursing homes, or ambulance services --- places where death is constantly imminent) actors/actresses, spies, folks involved in long sales cycles, and plenty of others, face somewhat similar challenges.
How do you perform a job which is wrought with emotional investment and a variety of moral dilemmas, and then walk away to act around peers who do not go through anything remotely similar?
The biggest difference in all of these and the hobby industry is barrier to entry. In the end, anyone (with very few exceptions) can get involved in the hobby as long as they either have a pussy or they have cash. Which means there's a lot of us who are simply unprepared for the psychological ramifications of the choices we're making.
And while I'm sympathetic to that, I also at least intellectually understand the risks. I also understand why I've made this decision, and the reasons far out weigh the issues I'll have to deal with.
I also know we learn best from our mistakes. Sometimes you just have to fuck it up badly enough, so you know, "Wow. I do not want to go through that again." Sometimes, that decision means leaving the hobby altogether. But sometimes it just means changing our behavior, or mentality in some way, to protect ourselves from making that mistake again.
But while making the mistake and learning from it is the best lesson teacher, the second best lesson teacher is hearing from other people the mistakes they've made, and trying to learn from it.
Which is why I'm so grateful for this forum, others like it, and the ones like ASPD that came before it. There are a lot of folks who have poured their energies into creating a place that newbies can learn from, as well as linking like minded folks into a fruitful relationship for both parties.
In any case, thanks for sharing your perspective, Poet Laureate. I think it's a very important one. I hope other people are able to learn from it.
Lots of interesting issues here, and I could give personal perspective on more than one, but I'll stick to the one I think I can best explain, the obsessive, clingy client:
I've been that guy. Not so much any more, but recently enough. The problem is this: some of you ladies are just too good at what you do, and when you couple that with a client whose SO has been saying no for too long, and whose need goes beyond the physical to the emotional, it's a recipe for disaster. All of a sudden a man with a chasm the size of the grand canyon has access to a woman who is saying yes to him whenever he has the funds to see her, and who seems to genuinely care about him. He finds it easy to rationalize in his mind that he's special, because after all, who among us doesn't want to feel special? Deep down he knows he's just another client, but he ignores that as long as he can. This is because he has that desperate need to be cared for, a need that his SO is not meeting. In these situations the sex truly is secondary. I've had mind-blowing Omigod sex with providers I only saw once. I've had run-of-the-mill sex with a provider I saw half a dozen times. The difference was that the lady I saw many times always acted like she wanted to be there. Not the IOP, but the illusion of caring. That's why I don't really give a damn whether it's a CBJ or BBBJ, whether it's mish or CG, whether I last five minutes or thirty. What I care about is the emotional intimacy, which is why kissing is so important to some of us. It's too easy to detach yourself from the act of sex, but it's much harder to detach from a prolonged, deep kiss.
Then there's Pretty Woman Syndrome, the deeply hidden, rarely talked about pipe dream that some hobbyists have. It revolves around finding a provider who decides she wants to give up the life, find one man to be with, and chooses you. Of course it's a fantasy. Of course it's not going to happen, and even if it did, it wouldn't be with me. But it's still out there as a possibility, because every once in a while it does happen.
So I see a lady, and I know there will be sex. I know there will be oral sex, which rarely happened in my twenty year marriage. I know I won't be nagged, I know she won't act as though she's doing me a favor, or only being with me because she feels guilty about all the times she's said no recently. I know she's going to pay attention to me, my feelings, my desires, my needs. She's going to pay attention to me! She's going to say yes to pretty much whatever I ask her to do (because I've read her reviews and know what not to ask). And some ladies wonder why some men get clingy, or obsess? My question is not why some do; it's why more men don't.
But we eventually figure it out. Sometimes with help, sometimes on our own, but either way it gets figured out. The desperation to find someone who cares gives way to a realization that we're looking for something in the hobby that it just isn't designed to give. We quit deluding ourselves, and learn to just enjoy the providers for what they are.
Like I said, I used to be that guy, and if you think me posting this isn't going to cause a shitload of problems for me, think again. But I think it's important enough that I'll take the heat, because I know there are other hobbyists out there in the same boat I was in, only they don't realize it, and they haven't yet gotten to the point where a provider or another hobbyist has enlightened them. I only hope for their sake that when it's done, it's done privately, gently, and with compassion.
Originally Posted by Poet Laureate