"How dare they?" I'll tell you how. I'm going to let you in on a little secret; this is a SHMB. People have opinions, popular ones and unpopular ones. Combine that with what I call keyboard anonymity (Internet bravery) and anything can happen and oftentimes does!
I agree she has a right to seek answers and the reviewer has a right to not divulge his reasons for any statements he made or his recommendation to her or the community.
Are we done with this thread? Originally Posted by scorpio31
No.
So long as there are people who have no qualms about lying, as long as comments can be posted in private and not put to the scrutiny of an opposing view, then this topic will remain a popular arguing point.