Is a really bad review considered to be in poor taste?

I saw someone last night and was considering writing a review. Not someone from here, but from backpage (although she did mention being on p411, which I haven't looked at).

Pretty much everything about the date was awful. Would a really terrible review be in bad form?

Write the review, but be honest and respectful. Reviews help others in making a desision wether to see a provider or not. Money is tight for most (both sides), we (men) want to spend it wisely and get the best mileage available.

The potential of a negative review resulted in this faux alert. Previously, this negative review caused the provider to post this fake one.

The review should all be truthful. Reviews are there to help people make decisions.

Good advice. If you must post reviews, negative or positive, do so gently. Too many harsh words can draw fire--or worse. And too many exuberant adjectives about how over-the-top, fantastic the lady was can make you seem like a high school kid.

Good advice. If you must post reviews, negative or positive, do so gently. Too many harsh words can draw fire--or worse. And too many exuberant adjectives about how over-the-top, fantastic the lady was can make you seem like a high school kid. Originally Posted by JDNorthface

That definitely makes sense.

I would just hate the idea of being the guy with one review, and it's a bad one.

My first review was a no.

That definitely makes sense.

I would just hate the idea of being the guy with one review, and it's a bad one. Originally Posted by dfwo

It doesn't have to be your last one. Those bad experiences give us judgment which in turn gives us good experiences. MB is right, if your NO helps other avoid a bad experience, you've done a service to the gents on this board--and maybe the lady herself.

My first review was a no. Originally Posted by MasterBaiter1996

ur next one will be a fuck yea!!!


i say write it. so the guys can avoid the same thing. if someone had seen this girl and posted bad review..u would have saved time and $. Just state how u felt and facts without harshness...

I saw someone last night and was considering writing a review. Not someone from here, but from backpage (although she did mention being on p411, which I haven't looked at).

Pretty much everything about the date was awful. Would a really terrible review be in bad form? Originally Posted by dfwo

Yes, bro write the review just like it went down. Be honest, you can't expect every review to be a yes. By not writing one, you're helping her promote bad service and you brethren here fall victim to it. We utilize the board for the purpose of obtaining information prior to seeing a girl, and the more the information the better.


Surely not every provider will be satisfied that you gave you her a no, and some may rebuttal with their side of the story or produce fabricated information, either way our members here are very good at sorting out the facts and drawing up a conclusion.

I would just hate the idea of being the guy with one review, and it's a bad one. Originally Posted by dfwo

As long as your honest I don't think you'll have to worry about any negative flank. True the WK's might ride in but the truth shall prevail my friend! There are plenty of lurkers who's only review is a no, their reason may be because they only wish to share the negative experience to warn the rest of the community.

I would write the review, but without degrading or humiliating the provider. Honest reviews can be done without being judgmental. The review is still one man's opinion though, because another guy might see the girl and have a completely different experience. So many men don't realize that we providers are just human beings, not a plastic doll that can be wound up to suit each and every guy that comes our way during a session. When a man treats me with respect and is kind and generous, as well as honest, he will increase his mileage a great deal.

Be honest, be as truthful as you can, but without attacking the girl.

It is hard to write an honest yet negative review without hurting some feelings. I would hate for the girls to review me as stinky and fat, small dicked, speaks poor English, etc. You gotta admit, these girls are really putting themselves out there, subjecting themselves to reviews. Quite brave!
However, if the girl is extremely hot looking, I will go see her anyway, in spite of a negative review, because beautiful broads are a joy to touch. Plus, women are moody, and some guys can't handle them well. If I can't handle them either, well, you warned me! Then it is my duty to also write a bad review. If enough add up, the trend must mean something.

That definitely makes sense.

I would just hate the idea of being the guy with one review, and it's a bad one. Originally Posted by dfwo

At least it would give you something to build on. Reading a man's review history is most times like seeing the evolution of a person. Bad experiences today may mean better experiences tomorrow.