I've never challenged someone before on this board or any other, but I did send her a PM right after your first post advising her that your comments were misleading. You may be a great tax guy, but you need to be way more careful about how you represent your credentials and capabilities (in the confidentiality sense). I am a CPA and a very experienced tax practitioner, I do know the landscape. I've worked with EA's, there are circumstances where I'm convinced they can get better results than I can. But, I will never work with anyone who should know better and who misrepresents his or her credentials or capabilities. It's out of line and you should not be allowed to hide behind some sort of "guardians" BS. You misrepresented yourself and your credentials, and and you need to be accountable for that. Sad part is that if you had not stepped over the line, you likely have the expertise to represent her well.
Originally Posted by engawg61
I do find it humerous that CPAs always seem to be up in arms when compared to EAs; and yes, it applies to me as well.
I've found that providers have to be VERY comfortable with someone, especially one of their clients, in order for them to be forthcoming with information. Let's face it, they are providing (no pun intended) their real names, social security numbers, and addresses. Not to mention how much they're really making.
I've always felt that's where CPAs tend to be more reliable than EAs. CPAs have so many guidelines and "codes of conduct" they have to abide by, not to mention the tremendous amount of education required (before and after license). And let's not forget about the CPA exam....
I've helped providers, and other hobbyists, in the past with their taxes, both current filings and tax problems. A recently retired provider had a real mess with a former client who wanted to barter with her. Turns out, the client was an EA. She asked me to review the documents prepared by the guy and, at first glance, there were staggering errors. I'm talking about name spelled incorrectly, numbers transposed on her SSN, etc. Talk about a "hack" job. We corrected everything and she was appreciative.
A bit of advice for the providers: Don't barter with someone who's assisting you with your financial affairs! Chances are, the "professional" won't take the job seriously....and, you most likely charge more per hour than they do!