It had rules.
Hookers could not follow said rules.
Mods said "hookers, please follow the rules or we will take it away"
Hookers still could not follow rules.
Mods took it down.
For heavens sake, can we forget that thread ever existed? It closed years ago, but my tummy still hurts just thinking about it. Pass me the Pepcid, please.
The reason that it failed wasn't as simple as some would have you believe, OP, nor did the blame rest entirely on the lovely shoulders of the providers. Yes, a few couldn't follow instructions if they were tattooed on their pretty noses (and most of them are gone now, interestingly), but too many cooks kept changing the recipe I started with, and interpreting the ingredients as they saw fit. Confusion certainly helped ruin the whole dish.
Leave it at that, before my ulcer erupts like Vesuvius.