For the love of grapes, don't moderate off-topic posts. Just let them play out the way they will. This is an adult website, let adults be adults and stop baby-sitting. When they start to get defamatory or openly hostile for no other reason that to be an asshole/cunt, then shut them down with a nice time-out and a private message explaining the time-out. You are honestly taking much of the joy out of this website when people can't tell slightly related jokes because it's "off-topic". FFS.
Originally Posted by johnnylongcaulking
I've always said the less interference by mods in discussions the better. But NEVER edit a thread to try to get it back on-topic? Nah, I don't think so. I write mostly in the legal forum, and I get annoyed when someone pulls a Roseanne Roseannadanna by misunderstanding a topic, then drones on and on about some irrelevant issue. Prudent moderation keeps discussions on track.
I've never noticed over-moderation on this site, in contrast to ASPD, where even the slightest deviation caused the mods to bring out The Gimp to thump the malefactor on the head.