There was an alert the other day with a dude's name in it. That thread disappeared completely. Why does one thread have info blocked out while the other thread is deleted?
I'm not criticizing MODs or members, but regarding the thread GP is asking about in this thread, a member just called a girl a thief with no details, I thought alerts were supposed to have more substance. The deleted thread did, but that was a provider calling out a John.
Originally Posted by JohnnyCap
Either you are mistaken or you mis-spoke. I assume you are talking about this thread, and it was not removed:
http://www.eccie.net/showthread.php?t=597244
It WAS heavily edited.... more than once, actually. But that was because it contained info that could have been easily used to identify the person discussed. It was not deleted.
Regarding the "thief" thread.... in this case, since the girl is not a member nor an established, well-known provider, a bit more leeway is allowed. Had this been an accusation about a member or verified provider, it probably would have been scrutinized more carefully, maybe "quarantined" until corroborating information was provided.
This is a confusing area, and tough to call sometimes. We want to protect members, yet everyone deserves privacy in their "real life"..... even if not a member here.
I will speak with the other Mods and try to clarify some of these concerns. I know that our actions regarding these issues are not always consistent. This is a difficult area, and maybe we overthink this at times. But better that than cause someone some undeserved grief in their private life. More to come....