why do we give money to Israel?

why do we give money to Israel?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p153TH6P7sY

we've given them, not loaned then, >100 Billion in 10 yrs...why exactly?

So they can keep the Arabs in check and take the brunt of blame for killing them off?

Aside from debating if we should aid Israel or not, the stats in the video are manipulated.

You want the blue pill or the red one?

Because we as a major power in the UN decided it was a wonderful idea to take the jewish people remaining in Eastern Europe after the holocost and give them their own land, which by the way did not belong to us or them to give away. We then decided in our infinate wisdom to plant them right in the middle of a reigon with 1000 of years of hatred towards them. So now we must pay to protect them because we were idiots to begin with.

because we were idiots to begin with.

There ya go.

Because we as a major power in the UN decided it was a wonderful idea to take the jewish people remaining in Eastern Europe after the holocost and give them their own land, which by the way did not belong to us or them to give away. We then decided in our infinate wisdom to plant them right in the middle of a reigon with 1000 of years of hatred towards them. So now we must pay to protect them because we were idiots to begin with. Originally Posted by dirty dog

You hit the nail on the head...the creation of Israel had nothing to do with religion or returning them "to the promise land". It was pure post WW II politics.

And this nonsense that somehow they are our ally against the big bad Arabs. Everytime we start a war in Mid East....which we do regularly...the first point is we tell them NOT to get involved, so the area does not blow up in our face.

I'm not advocating we drop our support of Israel....but we need to treat them as an equal ally, not as their rubber stamp. One small example was when the Palestinians sought to have a place in the UN....the entire world voted for them, except two countries...US & Israel.

And god forbid any of us question or suggest changes regarding adjustments or revaluation of our relationships with Israel....'cause that alone will bring out the cries of being anti-Jew.

Also notice if a public figure...be it entertainment or politicans makes anything close to an anti-Jewish comment, eveyone and their brother cracks down hard on the individual.

Now if there is anything close to anti-Black or Mexican or Asian....yea, there will be some backlash...but soon it is forgotten.

And no, I'm not anti-Jew....I am very anti-Zionist. Huge difference

And as far as someone saying, we let them take the blame for killing Arabs....the US has killed far more Arabs than Israel has. So that comment is the typical uneducated position many Americans take

EDIT: And I do agree with JD's post regarding why do we give Egypt so much $$$....but it is interesting when that thug Mubrak was running the show, we gave them the same amount of money as we do now. But I guess since he was pro-US there wasn't that question.

I agree we should cut back on both Egypt and Israel aid. But folks, like it or not, the Muslim Brotherhood was voted in by the people. That's the thing about democracy...sometimes the party voted in, may not be the party that is US-approved

Maybe you should ask why we give money to Egypt. Makes more sense to be concerned about the Muslim Brotherhood than the "Israel" lobby that Hagel fears so much.

One night w/ Bar and I'll call it even.

I recommend a book called The High Cost of Peace. It is about the middle east peace process during the Clinton years. It is written by an Israeli, and he is of course pro-Israel. But it is a very long and well researched book that gives a glimpse into Israeli politics and the entire region. There are no easy black/white answers in the middle east....but the quick and dirty answer to why we funnel so much money to the region is that it buys us influence.

Also important to know is that the vast majority of the aid to Israel is conditioned on their buying US military equipment. Think of it as a stimulous plan for military contractors. This might piss alot of people off: but arrangememts such as this ensure that our nation can build its own military equipment...very important in a digital age.

1. They are the only democracy in the region, and in general uphold our values.

2. They are a good ally. In fact, we would probably be a better ally to them if we would tell them to take care of business themselves, instead of always holding them back.

3. They are some bad-ass mofo's. Man for man quite possibly the best armed forces on the planet. As good of fighters, and as good of allies, as the Aussies.

Those are good enough for me.

Israel is basically the USA's baby. There are lots of influential Jewish people that lobby to assist Israel. Plus on the whole the USA is Christian. I don't think either could imagine the holy land in Muslim control. Don't worry so much about the money we give. Israel provides stability in the region as well as a friendly warm water point of entry to the Middle East. If the US turned its back on Israel it would be bad for business to all our partners that need a steady supply of oil. Money well spent that ultimately saves Muslims lives. Our goal is to get the region on board with democracy and capitalism with the hope it brings peace.

Israel is very tough, crazy as it sounds, perhaps even more effective than the US pound for pound. This is only be because they have to be. They are surrounded, if war starts they have to take and hold ground quickly. So every thing is high speed low drag. All deterrence though as I'm sure the US will always be quick to fight their battles. Lastly it's wrong to think all Jews and Muslims hate eachother. Most are civil hardworking people that want peace for their families. It's the governments that fuel the fire.

Personally, I would nuke the entire region, doze it flat, pave it and build a giant walmart.

Personally, I would nuke the entire region, doze it flat, pave it and build a giant walmart. Originally Posted by dirty dog

I like how you think

I never hear about giving money to isireal and then having to raise taxes here
thats why I asked
shit, I need cofffee

Because we as a major power in the UN decided it was a wonderful idea to take the jewish people remaining in Eastern Europe after the holocost and give them their own land, which by the way did not belong to us or them to give away. We then decided in our infinate wisdom to plant them right in the middle of a reigon with 1000 of years of hatred towards them. So now we must pay to protect them because we were idiots to begin with. Originally Posted by dirty dog

100% spot on.

I'd have to check my history books, but I think the U.N. got formed right after Israel.

Sometimes we win, sometimes we lose. Look at how we meddled in Iran, starting in the late 1940s. Overthrow the government, support the Shah of Iran. Fast forward to the 1970s, the Shah gets deposed, religious nuts take over. Hostages get taken, Reagan gets an undeserved win for nothing, like most of his Presidency.

Saddam Hussein used to be our best friend over there when the Shah got deposed. Look at the pictures of Don Rumsfeld shaking hands with Sadam ca 1982. And 20 years later we're taking on Saddam Hussein. And so it goes...