For the record, Carson Palmer has been traded (twice) during his career...."booted" sounds a little more like he was released outright and that's not been the case.
First, in 2011, after refusing to report to Bengals training camp and asking ownership to trade him. Cincy's "cheap repairs" to plug offensive problems for the 2010 season (they signed T.O., remember?) lead to a 4-12 finish. Carson basically had had enough of Mike Brown's mismanagement and simply wanted out of the organization.
After taking Andy Dalton in that April's draft, Bengals traded him midway thru the 2011 season to Oakland for a first round pick and a conditional second rounder.
After the 2012 season, Arizona, needing a qb, negotiated a trade with the Raiders and there you have it. Carson Palmer's not your typical journeyman qb....he could play for a LOT of teams around the NFL. While he can be erratic at times, I'd have to say many of of his passes were pinpoint yesterday.
On the flipside, Weeden's passes were all over the place. He looked tentative and uncertain of himself and lacked that spark as to how to run the offense properly. The two picks he threw were clearly on him. Poorly placed....he looked exactly like he did during his short stint in Cleveland and in every preseason game we saw him in this summer.
Personally speaking, he has does not have an NFL arm and yesterday's game was a clear example of why Dallas should have never tendered him a contract in the first place. The mobile Colt McCoy would have been a much better choice for the Cowboys. He'd been a backup in San Fran last season, if you'll recall.
As far as releasing Romo, you might want to check that; I don't think it'll clear up the salary cap space you're suggesting. It would throw Dallas back into Cap Hell once again.
Nonetheless, drafting a "franchise quarterback" requires timing and proper position.....neither of which I doubt will happen for Dallas per the 2015 May draft. Who, playing this season at the collegiate level, might one suggest the Cowboys take? I don't see an Andrew Luck, a Peyton Manning or a Tom Brady starting for anyone out there for any colleges today.
Finding that "franchise quarterback" is not quite as easy as it looks. The first two names I mentioned (Luck....Manning) it took Indy having the worst record in the NFL both times. I doubt Jerry wants to bite the bullet and allow this thing to melt down completely to achieve that. And to get a "Tom Brady" in the 6th round? lol....good luck with that!
But then how many teams has Palmer played for and been booted?
I say hand Romo his annuity and send him home, free up some salary cap, get through what's left of the season once again then draft a franchise quarterback with a history of winning big games. Rape, assault, manslaughter and theft convictions optional for Jerry's boys.
Originally Posted by phildo