Again you are wrong. She has to sign it and hand it back to him.Those two words....two little words....with so much power...."reasonable suspicion". What gave him a "reasonable suspicion". Out of state plates? She was black (it has to be asked)? She was smoking? I can't see how all of that adds up to "reasonable suspicion".
But if he has a reasonable suspicion that there is contraband in the vehicle in which she is sitting he has sufficient legal basis to remove her from the vehicle and search it in the immediate area around her. She was resisting a search when she refused to get out of the vehicle.
BTW: Just for your future contacts ..
.... blowing smoke in an officer's face would be an "assault on a peace officer"!
At that point he as 3 reasons to arrest her: She's an out of state motorist who committed a traffic violation, she's resisting a search of her vehicle for contraband, and she assaulted a peace officer. Once she begins to "struggle" with him, she's resisting arrest.
She's taken a simple traffic violation and escalated it into higher offenses and ended up in jail for it ....
.. so you still haven't offered an "alternative" ... besides "letting her drive off"! Originally Posted by LexusLover
Those two words....two little words....with so much power...."reasonable suspicion". What gave him a "reasonable suspicion". Out of state plates? She was black (it has to be asked)? She was smoking? I can't see how all of that adds up to "reasonable suspicion".Now you know LL the dogface bitch boy is not going to listen to reason when it comes to black folks.
I've had my own run in with a rookie state trooper (this guy was on the job for less than a year). We spent two hours on the side of the road with him asking for permission to search my car at 3 AM before he gave up with a threat. I just told him that I would wait for him to wake up a judge at 4 AM to get that warrant he needed and have to explain that he had NO "reasonable suspicion". The guy didn't want to admit that he screwed up or that he was kind of pissed that I refused him, a state trooper. My initial offense? As he approached me from the opposite direction on the state highway....he turned on his siren and lights just as he got to me. I did what you're supposed to do. I swerved to the side of the road to give him room. He claimed that he saw me swerve and thought that I was under the influence. I think he was more pissed when he had me recite the presidents backwards and I was down to Millard Filmore when he told me to quit. He probably won't have known if I had gotten it wrong after Hoover.
No, people make mistakes and this woman died for his mistake. I worry that he might do it again if he gets away with it.
Someone who does not pay attention to this stuff had a comment that I thought was interesting....why was Sandra Bland in jail three days later for a traffic stop? Long weekend? She never saw a judge? That seems weird when you think about it. A accused thug can walk and someone who makes a lane change is stuck? I think a reasonable judge who hear the story and throw out most of this, if not all of it and call it even for time served. What was the name of the judge? Originally Posted by JD Barleycorn
Those two words....two little words....with so much power...."reasonable suspicion". What gave him a "reasonable suspicion". Out of state plates? She was black (it has to be asked)? She was smoking? I can't see how all of that adds up to "reasonable suspicion" Originally Posted by JD BarleycornYou, like many, fail on two levels: You focus on one element of the contact, and base your conclusion on one personal experience of your own.
You, like many, fail on two levels: You focus on one element of the contact, and base your conclusion on one personal experience of your own.
Rewind the "tape" to the beginning of the contact, and evaluate the events.
Some where out there in internet land you can find "factors" considered by patrol officers when evaluating a driver's ability to drive and/or whether or not their are impaired ....
1. Bland passes the trooper who is on a traffic stop.
2. He is behind her some distance after the stop.
3. She changes lanes without a signal into his lane with him behind her.
4. He pulls her over.
5. He casually and politely asks her for her DL and about where she is going.
6. He was on the passenger side.
7. He returns to present her with a WARNING TICKET to sign.
8. She was "irritated" and began to question him about stopping her.
9. She starts up with the cigarette and he asks her to put it out.
10. Up to that point the trooper engaged in no negative activities.
11. She did, when all she had to do was keep her mouth shut and sign.
As was reported she was "intoxicated" on a prohibited substance.
12. Belligerence was her response.
13. She was still being detained.
14. He asked her to step out of the vehicle, which he can do lawfully.
15. She refused.
16. After several orders to exit, he reached in after telling her he would.
17. She slapped him while she was sitting in the car.
18. ........End of story. She goes to jail.
Now you might want to explain why an officer had you on the side of the road for 2 hours? Or would you rather not? You failed to mention what State you were in when an officer asked you to recite the President's backwards for a "field sobriety test" ...... I take it you didn't hit the officer during your stop. Originally Posted by LexusLover
You have all the answers lexie, I got a couple of questions for you.What about it lexie?
1- Where was the officers female pardner while this was occurring? In the patrol car smoking?
2- Sandra never asked for the driver license or any other pertinent material he had taken from her, just asked for the ticket. If he returned it to her, why was he reluctant to give her the ticket? Warning tickets require no signature.
3- Why did she say that she changed lanes to get out of his way when he turned around?
I am sure you can clear this up for me. Originally Posted by i'va biggen
You have all the answers lexie, I got a couple of questions for you.What "female pardner"? He was by himself in the patrol unit.
1- Where was the officers female pardner while this was occurring? In the patrol car smoking?
2- Sandra never asked for the driver license or any other pertinent material he had taken from her, just asked for the ticket. If he returned it to her, why was he reluctant to give her the ticket? Warning tickets require no signature.
3- Why did she say that she changed lanes to get out of his way when he turned around?
I am sure you can clear this up for me. Originally Posted by i'va biggen
What "female pardner"? He was by himself in the patrol unit.Female officer testified she saw Bland kick the officer.
Warning Ticket ... Texas Department of Public Safety
She didn't "changed lanes to get out of his way when he turned around.."
dd
He turned around and then she changed lanes ..... WITHOUT SIGNALING.
Let me re-post just to prove your ignorance:
Do you see the little line immediately below the printed words ...
"SIGNATURE" Originally Posted by LexusLover
Female pardner testified she saw Bland kick the officer.He didn't have a "pardner" .... The female that appeared was a local officer ... she arrived with another male officer in the same uniform (dark/blue or black). The Texas DPS troopers wear kaki/light brown uniforms ... for regular patrol. The trooper called for a local assistance to transport to their jail ... In Texas DPS troopers use local jails to hold their prisoners. In Texas many DPS patrol units don't have cages .. and I can imagine he didn't want asshole-Bland sitting in his vehicle .... front or back.
Was that your ticket? i have received warning tickets in three states, never had to sign one on the line for signature. If you do not have to appear there is no reason for it. Is it to cover Texas officers ass?
Originally Posted by i'va biggen
You know as well as i do that JD embellished that story by about one hour and fifty five minutes!
Now you might want to explain why an officer had you on the side of the road for 2 hours? Or would you rather not? You failed to mention what State you were in when an officer asked you to recite the President's backwards for a "field sobriety test" ...... I take it you didn't hit the officer during your stop. Originally Posted by LexusLover
He didn't have a "pardner" .... The female that appeared was a local officer ... she arrived with another male officer in the same uniform (dark/blue or black). The Texas DPS troopers wear kaki/light brown uniforms ... for regular patrol. The trooper called for a local assistance to transport to their jail ... In Texas DPS troopers use local jails to hold their prisoners. In Texas many DPS patrol units don't have cages .. and I can imagine he didn't want asshole-Bland sitting in his vehicle .... front or back.Asshole Bland------Well that explains your approval of the asshole who stopped her. You sidestepped the other questions, so we are done. If you regard a burnt out bulb, and being rousted because you ride a m/c crimes then go fuck yourself.
If you take the time to listen to the audio you will hear Bland complaining after she was cuffed that she was just "trying to sign" like he asked .... she never touched his "clip board" with the ticket on it when he put it up to the window ... she was smoking .... and slapped him while she was still in her car.
One signs the ticket for the officer to confirm the contact .... many agencies, DPS included, are not supposed to give "verbal warnings" ... they have to be written ... and the violator signs ... gets a copy and the trooper retains the original...... the answer to your first asshole question is "no"!
Now the last thing ... what happens in the 3 states where you have committed crimes ... doesn't apply to Texas. Assholes like Bland go to jail. Originally Posted by LexusLover
He didn't have a "pardner" .... The female that appeared was a local officer ... she arrived with another male officer in the same uniform (dark/blue or black). The Texas DPS troopers wear kaki/light brown uniforms ... for regular patrol. The trooper called for a local assistance to transport to their jail ... In Texas DPS troopers use local jails to hold their prisoners. In Texas many DPS patrol units don't have cages .. and I can imagine he didn't want asshole-Bland sitting in his vehicle .... front or back.another demonstration of Eva's stupidity
If you take the time to listen to the audio you will hear Bland complaining after she was cuffed that she was just "trying to sign" like he asked .... she never touched his "clip board" with the ticket on it when he put it up to the window ... she was smoking .... and slapped him while she was still in her car.
One signs the ticket for the officer to confirm the contact .... many agencies, DPS included, are not supposed to give "verbal warnings" ... they have to be written ... and the violator signs ... gets a copy and the trooper retains the original...... the answer to your first asshole question is "no"!
Now the last thing ... what happens in the 3 states where you have committed crimes ... doesn't apply to Texas. Assholes like Bland go to jail. Originally Posted by LexusLover